The women in white, black and gray
Where a woman in white, black or gray is reported at the places we research, how strong the accounts are, and what records show.
- Research guide
- Published
- 5 min read
At a glance
A woman dressed in white, or sometimes in black, gray or blue, is one of the figures that comes up most often at the places we have researched. She turns up at cemeteries, forts, house museums, an inn, a library and a prison, but few of these stories trace back to a named or clearly identified witness. Where we could check the records, the woman the legend says she is often does not fit them.
- 25researched places
- 15states
- 25places you can visit
Where she appears
At our places, one large group is cemeteries and the roads beside them. Drivers near Resurrection Cemetery in Justice, Illinois, reported a woman in white, and the legends of Bachelor's Grove Cemetery include one too. A woman in black is said to sit by a grave at Stepp Cemetery, and a ghost-tour website describes one at Lone Fir Cemetery. Camp Chase Confederate Cemetery in Ohio has its Lady in Gray, and guides at the Unitarian Church in Charleston speak of a Lady in White in the churchyard.
House museums are the other large group. The Gray Lady of Liberty Hall in Kentucky is the oldest version in our records. A woman in black is described at White Hall and Baker Mansion, a woman in white at the Vaile Mansion and Jane Addams Hull-House, a Lady in Gray at the Owens-Thomas House and the Spanish Governor's Palace, and a woman in blue colonial dress at the George Wythe House. A book of Carnton ghost stories includes a Lady in White.
Military sites have her too: the Lady in Black of Fort Warren, a "white lady" at Fort Monroe and a Lady in White in the legends of Chickamauga Battlefield. So do public buildings: the Grey Lady of Willard Library, the Blue Lady of the Story Inn, a woman in white at the Bird Cage Theatre, at Old Joliet Prison, at Eloise and in Portland's Shanghai Tunnels, and a "Lady in Black" in a 1980s photograph at the Joshua Ward House in Salem.
When the stories were published
The oldest versions we found are written ones. Rebecca Averill, a Liberty Hall neighbor and family friend, wrote that she saw the Gray Lady in 1911, and a 1922 Courier-Journal article calling her the "Lady in Gray" helped fix the name. Edward Rowe Snow printed the Fort Warren legend in 1935, introducing it as a story offered "without the slightest guarantee that any part of it is true." Willard Library says its Grey Lady first appeared to a custodian in 1937, but the earliest telling we found is the library's own.
From 1980 the sources are drivers and ghost-hunting groups: police calls at Resurrection Cemetery in 1980, a 1991 photograph at Bachelor's Grove and a 2006 televised investigation at the Bird Cage Theatre. Most sources from 2018 on are tour guides, staff and tourism sites.
How strong the evidence is
Few of these figures rest on traceable accounts. Liberty Hall, rated Well Documented, has Averill's description of a figure in a gray bonnet and shawl, though she also recorded the family stories and is not fully independent of them. At Resurrection Cemetery, rated Documented Accounts, several motorists called police over one weekend in August 1980 and police found several witnesses, though none is named. At the Bird Cage Theatre, the two lead investigators of the Ghost Hunters series each described a woman in white in 2006; filming together, they count as one origin. At White Hall, ghost hunter and author Patti Starr told a newspaper of a woman in black in the hallways.
Much of the rest comes from people who work at the site or sell tours of it. Colonial Williamsburg staff described the George Wythe House figure without a named witness or date, and the Shanghai Tunnels claims came from a group that runs tunnel tours. At the Unitarian Church a former guide described no sighting at all. The Old Joliet Prison figure is a guest's photograph relayed by a guide, and the Bird Cage Theatre's "Lady in White" hallway is the operator's marketing.
Photographs are not accounts of an experience, so we do not count them. Author Michael Kleen notes that the figure in the Bachelor's Grove image appears to cast a shadow, suggesting a real person.
What the records show
The legends often give the figure the name of a real woman from the place's past, and the records rarely support it. Many Story Inn guests identify the Blue Lady as Jane Story, wife of the village's founder, but the Blue Lady Room is in a store built in 1916, decades after the Story family left the area in the early 1880s. A popular belief names the Willard Library figure as Louise Carpenter, but she did not die at the library, as staff have pointed out, and the library says no one knows who she is.
At Camp Chase, a heritage-group researcher argues that the woman a later version names was too young in 1864, and lived too far away, for the romance the story gives her. We found no record of the killing in the Fort Monroe story, no historical source for any death at the Spanish Governor's Palace, and no documentation that the Owens-Thomas figure is Margaret Thomas. At Fort Warren, Snow cited no records for the court-martial cases of sentries he linked to the Lady in Black, and we found none.
How we rate these stories
We rate the reports, not the figure. A legend retold many times counts once, staff and tour accounts count as one origin, and photographs do not count. Read more in our methodology and the evidence report.
Notable places in this guide
The best-documented places the guide draws on. Each page has the full history, every account we traced and the sources.

Historic house · Frankfort, KY
Liberty Hall Historic Site
Liberty Hall in Frankfort is the Federal-style home Senator John Brown built from 1796, now a museum.
Well DocumentedTours only
Cemetery · Justice, IL
Resurrection Cemetery
Resurrection Cemetery is a Catholic cemetery on Archer Avenue in Justice, Illinois.
Documented AccountsOutside only
Cemetery · IL
Bachelor's Grove Cemetery
Bachelor's Grove is a small 19th-century settlers' cemetery inside a Cook County forest preserve near Midlothian.
Documented AccountsOutside only
All 25 places in this guide
Cemetery
Resurrection Cemetery
Justice, Illinois
Cemetery
Bachelor's Grove Cemetery
Illinois
Cemetery
Stepp Cemetery
Indiana
Cemetery
Lone Fir Cemetery
Portland, Oregon
Cemetery
Camp Chase Confederate Cemetery
Columbus, Ohio
Church
Unitarian Church in Charleston and churchyard
Charleston, South Carolina
Historic house
Liberty Hall Historic Site
Frankfort, Kentucky
Historic house
White Hall State Historic Site
Kentucky
Historic house
Baker Mansion
Altoona, Pennsylvania
Historic house
Vaile Mansion
Independence, Missouri
Museum
Jane Addams Hull-House Museum
Chicago, Illinois
Historic house
Owens-Thomas House & Slave Quarters
Savannah, Georgia
Museum
Spanish Governor's Palace
San Antonio, Texas
Historic house
George Wythe House
Williamsburg, Virginia
Historic house
Carnton
Franklin, Tennessee
Fort
Fort Warren
Boston, Massachusetts
Fort
Fort Monroe National Monument
Hampton, Virginia
Battlefield
Chickamauga Battlefield, Chickamauga and Chattanooga National Military Park
Fort Oglethorpe, Georgia
Library
Willard Library
Evansville, Indiana
Hotel
Story Inn
Indiana
Theater
Bird Cage Theatre
Tombstone, Arizona
Prison
Old Joliet Prison
Joliet, Illinois
Former asylum
Eloise
Westland, Michigan
Tunnel
Shanghai Tunnels
Portland, Oregon
Hotel
Joshua Ward House
Salem, Massachusetts
Written from our published research and reviewed by the editor. Send a correction.















