← Indiana Story Inn
Story Inn
History and the Blue Lady
Indiana
Story Inn is a country inn and restaurant in the 1916 general store of Story, a tiny Brown County village founded on Dr. George Story's 1850s farm.
What do we know about Story Inn?
The Blue Lady rests on guest-book entries, staff and owner accounts and one 2005 paranormal investigation known only secondhand. The earliest account we could trace is a 2002 student newspaper article. Details drift between tellings (a woman with blue eyes, cherry tobacco, and in one 2004 magazine note a pipe-smoking ghost). The popular identification with Jane Story is unsupported, and the room is in a building put up decades after the Story family left the village.
Our rating of the reports about Story Inn: Unverified. A haunted reputation or legend, but no traceable account of an experience so far. The rating describes the evidence for the reports, not whether the place is haunted.
- Reported accounts
- 2
- Counted for the rating
- 0
- Research sources
- 6
Counted for the rating: independent accounts we could trace to a witness. Retellings of the same story count once, and staff passing on what visitors said aren’t counted. How we count
Reported experiences don’t establish a supernatural cause.
Read our evidence assessment →The hauntings
Accounts, encounters and stories associated with Story Inn.
What has been reported?
- Doors
- Apparitions
- Smells
- Moving objects
Phenomena described in accounts associated with this location — not independently verified events.
Reported experiences
2 published and reported accounts, each assessed by its source.
Account 01 · January 23, 2002 · 4 versions
Guests' room journal entries, 2002
In 2002 the Indiana Daily Student reported that guests had written in the Blue Lady Room's journal that she slams doors, flushes the toilet at night and sometimes appears, and that turning on the blue bedside lamp may bring her out.[3]
- Doors
- Apparitions
- Smells
Published accountReported by Guests' room journal entries, summarized by the Indiana Daily Student (2002)Note: Guests are unnamed and undated; journal entries were summarized, not quoted.
Read full account ›
In 2002 the Indiana Daily Student reported that guests had written in the Blue Lady Room's journal that she slams doors, flushes the toilet at night and sometimes appears, and that turning on the blue bedside lamp may bring her out.[3]
The inn's general manager told the Indiana Daily Student in 2002 that he had felt the Blue Lady's presence while working late in his office next to her room, and described her as friendly.[3]
Indianapolis Monthly in 2004 described the Blue Lady room as said to be haunted by a pipe-smoking ghost.[4]
Later accounts describe a woman with icy blue eyes seen by the bed or in the mirror when the blue lamp is lit, a lingering smell of cherry tobacco and blue ribbons left behind, and say an owner found matching accounts decades apart in old guest books.[5][6]
Note: A feeling of presence, not a sighting; from inn staff.
Note: A one-line, unattributed mention.
Note: Retellings drawing on guest books and the owner; no individual witness is named.
Account 02 · August 22, 2016
Hoosier Paranormal, 2016
According to The Lineup, the Hoosier Paranormal group investigated the inn in December 2005 and reported orbs, doors opening and closing and objects falling from shelves, which it attributed to the Blue Lady and a male ghost.[5]
- Doors
- Moving objects
Published accountReported by Hoosier Paranormal (2005), as reported by The Lineup (2016)Note: Known only secondhand; the group's own report was not found.
Read full account ›
According to The Lineup, the Hoosier Paranormal group investigated the inn in December 2005 and reported orbs, doors opening and closing and objects falling from shelves, which it attributed to the Blue Lady and a male ghost.[5]
Legends & disputed stories
Stories told about the place that the records don’t confirm.
- Legend
Many guests identify the Blue Lady as Jane Story, wife of the village's founder.[5]
What the research shows: No evidence is offered; the room is in a store built in 1916, decades after the Story family left the area in the early 1880s.
Before you go
Planning a visit?
Open to visitors
Parts of the inside are open to the public.
Access details ›
A working inn and restaurant in the former general store at Story; the Blue Lady Room is a guest room, so only overnight guests can see it. Check the official site for bookings and restaurant hours.
Entry
Paid entry
Access last checked November 16, 2026. Confirm times and prices before you travel.
The history of Story Inn
Story Inn is a country inn and restaurant in the 1916 general store of Story, a tiny Brown County village founded on Dr. George Story's 1850s farm. Guests have long written in room journals about the "Blue Lady," said to appear when the blue bedside lamp is lit, often with a smell of cherry tobacco. A 2002 general manager said he felt her presence. Rooms can be booked.
- Established
- 1916
- Also known as
- Wheeler-Hedrick General Store
The village of Story
According to its National Register nomination, sometime between 1851 and 1855 Dr. George P. Story, his wife Jane and their three sons moved from Ohio to Van Buren Township in Brown County and settled on 173 acres. Dr. Story farmed and practiced medicine until he left the county in the early 1880s. In 1882 a post office named Story opened, and Dr. Arnold S. Griffitt, who took over the Story land, set up a dry goods store.
The store at the heart of today's inn is the second on the site. The first burned in November 1915, and Alra and Mary Wheeler built the present two-story store in 1916. The Hedrick family ran it from 1924 to 1969.
From store to inn
In 1978 a couple bought the store and several nearby buildings. They gradually closed the store, turned the ground floor into a restaurant and, after moving their family elsewhere, made the upstairs into guest rooms, creating the Story Inn. The village was listed on the National Register as the Story Historic District on March 11, 2019.
The Blue Lady
The inn's ghost lives, it is said, in a room above the old store. In 2002 the Indiana Daily Student reported that guests wrote in that room's journal that the Blue Lady slams doors, flushes the toilet at night and sometimes appears, and that switching on the blue lamp by the bed might bring her out. The general manager said he had felt her presence while working late next door and called her friendly.
Later tellings add detail. Indianapolis Monthly in 2004 called the Blue Lady room the haunt of a pipe-smoking ghost. A 2016 article by The Lineup describes a woman with icy blue eyes seen by the bed or in the mirror, a lingering smell of cherry tobacco and blue ribbons left behind, and says an owner found matching accounts decades apart in old guest books. The same article says the Hoosier Paranormal group investigated in December 2005 and reported orbs, doors opening and closing and objects falling.
Many guests identify the Blue Lady as Jane Story, the founder's wife. No source offers evidence for this, and the room is in a store built in 1916, long after the Story family left.
Through the years
1851–1855
Story family settles
Sometime between 1851 and 1855 Dr. George P. Story, his wife Jane and their three sons moved from Ohio to Van Buren Township, Brown County, and settled on 173 acres that later became the village of Story; he…
Read more ›
Sometime between 1851 and 1855 Dr. George P. Story, his wife Jane and their three sons moved from Ohio to Van Buren Township, Brown County, and settled on 173 acres that later became the village of Story; he farmed and practiced medicine there until the early 1880s.[1][2]
Caveat: Public radio and the inn give 1851 as the founding year.
1882
Story post office opens
On May 25, 1882, a post office named Story was established, and Dr. Arnold S. Griffitt, who had taken over the former Story land, opened a dry goods store.[1]
1916
Present store built
The first store burned in November 1915, and Alra and Mary Wheeler built the present two-story general store in 1916; the Hedrick family owned and ran it from 1924 to 1969.[1]
1978
Story Inn established
In 1978 a couple bought the store and several nearby buildings, gradually closed the store, turned its ground floor into a restaurant and later made guest rooms on the second floor, establishing the Story Inn.[1]
The research conclusion
Why it has this rating
No traceable account of an experience: the 2002 Indiana Daily Student summarized unnamed guests' journal entries, the general manager described only a feeling of presence, and the 2005 Hoosier Paranormal investigation is known only from a 2016 retelling that does not say where the group reported it. The identification of the Blue Lady as Jane Story conflicts with the building's 1916 date.
Read the full written assessment ›
The village's history is carefully documented in the 2019 National Register nomination, which draws on deeds, tax records and oral histories.
The Blue Lady rests on guest-book entries, staff and owner accounts and one 2005 paranormal investigation known only secondhand. The earliest account we could trace is a 2002 student newspaper article. Details drift between tellings (a woman with blue eyes, cherry tobacco, and in one 2004 magazine note a pipe-smoking ghost). The popular identification with Jane Story is unsupported, and the room is in a building put up decades after the Story family left the village.
The sources behind the story
6 research references support this entry.
1National Park Service, NPGalleryStory Historic District, National Register of Historic Places Registration Form (NRIS 100003500) Register or nomination · Reference 01
Story Historic District, National Register of Historic Places Registration Form (NRIS 100003500). National Park Service, NPGallery, 2019-03-11.
Detailed nomination drawing on deeds, tax duplicates, census records and oral histories. Reliable for the Story family's arrival, the 1882 post office, the 1915 fire, the 1916 store and the inn's creation from 1978. Prepared with the inn's support (Story Inn & Restaurant / Indiana Landmarks). Says nothing about ghosts.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
2Indiana Public Broadcasting NewsHistoric Town of Story, Indiana For Sale Television or radio · Reference 02
Barbara Brosher, Historic Town of Story, Indiana For Sale. Indiana Public Broadcasting News, 2019-04-04.
Public radio news on the 2019 sale listing of the village (not the inn business). Gives 1851 as the founding year and confirms the recent National Register listing; no ghost content.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
3Indiana Daily StudentA storied inn Newspaper · Reference 03
Natalie A. Trout, A storied inn. Indiana Daily Student, 2002-01-23.
Indiana University student newspaper. The earliest traceable account found: summarizes unnamed guests' journal entries and quotes the general manager by name. Its history (checkerboard 'since the 1850s', 'Doc Story bought the village') is loose and not used.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
4Indianapolis MonthlyStory Inn: Middle of Nowhere, But Worth the Drive Magazine · Reference 04
Cara McDonald (2004 sidebar), Story Inn: Middle of Nowhere, But Worth the Drive. Indianapolis Monthly, 2004.
Travel and dining compilation; the 2004 sidebar mentions the Blue Lady room in passing as haunted by a 'pipe-smoking ghost', unattributed.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
5The LineupA Haunting at the Story Inn: The Tale of the Blue Lady Website · Reference 05
Gary Sweeney, A Haunting at the Story Inn: The Tale of the Blue Lady. The Lineup, 2016-08-22.
Ghost-story website feature, also reposted by America's Most Haunted. The fullest version of the legend; relies on guest-book accounts and the owner's statements and summarizes a 2005 Hoosier Paranormal investigation without linking to it. Offers no evidence for the Jane Story identification.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
6Indiana Public Media (The INbox)4 Haunted Sites in the Hoosier State Television or radio · Reference 06
4 Haunted Sites in the Hoosier State. Indiana Public Media (The INbox), 2019-04-15.
Public-media listicle with Rachel Carter contributing. Retells the legend (blue lamp, blue eyes, cherry tobacco) without naming any witness; links to the inn's own room page.
Accessed November 16, 2026.




















