Phantom lights
Lights reported at our places, from the Paulding Light and Moonville Tunnel to cemeteries: what is traceable, what is legend, and what records show.
- Research guide
- Published
- 5 min read
At a glance
Lights are among the things most often reported at the places we have researched: a light seen from a roadside, lanterns on old railroad lines, glows in empty towers and balls of light in museums and cemeteries. At a few places named or clearly identified people describe seeing a light, and at the Paulding Light no one disputes that a light is seen. Most other light stories rest on legend, tour marketing or unnamed visitors.
- 24researched places
- 11states
- 21places you can visit
Lanterns on roads, rails and bridges
One group of stories is told as a lantern carried by someone who died there. The best-known legend of the Paulding Light in Michigan says it is the lantern of a railroad brakeman killed trying to stop a train; other versions make it the train itself or a relative searching with a lantern. At Moonville Tunnel in Ohio, a railroad man's lantern is said to swing at night, a story the state retells on its forest map as a legend. At Squire's Castle, also in Ohio, Squire's wife is said to carry a red lantern, and Bacon's Castle in Virginia has a red fireball said to float from an old church site across the fields to the house.
Visitors are also said to see lights at Poinsett Bridge in South Carolina and the Old Alton Bridge in Texas, and published authors have described mists and lights at Gore Orphanage Road in Ohio.
Lights in towers, windows and empty buildings
A second group is a light where none should be. At the Old Presque Isle Lighthouse in Michigan, the caretaker said that in May 1992, a few months after her husband's death, she saw a light glowing at the top of the tower, though she knew the lamp had been disconnected years before. Unnamed visitors describe a red glow in the dark windows of Squire's Castle. A 1938 Federal Writers' Project guide already told of strange lights at the LaLaurie Mansion in Louisiana, now a private building.
Unattributed sources also describe lights in an old church at Mammoth Cave National Park, the locked house at the Jesse James Farm, White Hall and a mausoleum at Bellefontaine Cemetery. At Waverly Hills Sanatorium a co-owner said she saw lights move from one room to the roof, and at Eloise the owner said he saw a light flicker on sealed upper floors.
Balls of light in museums and cemeteries
The third group is a ball of light. A great-granddaughter of the Caldwells said that while giving a tour of the Conrad-Caldwell House she saw a ball of light fly past, then a second. Two paranormal group members said they watched a ball of light move toward a camera during 2015 night tours at Fort Concho; the camera did not record it. At Bachelor's Grove Cemetery in Illinois, where floating blue and red lights are part of the legends, the Ghost Research Society collected accounts of a man who chased a baseball-sized blue light in the early 1970s and a woman who said she passed her hand through it in December 1971.
Other cemetery lights come with no witness: green orbs over graves at Cave Hill Cemetery, lights in the cemeteries of The Ridges and strange lights at Boothill Graveyard.
How strong the evidence is, and what the records show
Moonville has the oldest published report we found: an 1895 Chillicothe Daily Gazette item in which a freight crew said a figure in white with a lantern stood on the track and swung the light. We have seen it only as a transcription, and the same paper printed several items that year about pranksters dressing as ghosts. The versions disagree on who the lantern man was and when he died, and the 1859 newspaper item describes a fall from the cars, not a man struck while signaling.
The Paulding Light, rated Documented Accounts, has the strongest set of accounts in this group. In 2016 three friends watching together described to the Detroit Free Press a flickering light that brightened and dimmed, and the owner of the local general store said he had seen it countless times. These accounts do not bear on the light's cause. The Free Press dates the first sighting to 1966, but we found no record of that report, and Michigan Tech says talk of the light began in the 1960s.
At Old Presque Isle, others put the glow down to distant lights reflecting in the lantern glass, and we found no Coast Guard record of the inspections a 2017 magazine feature mentions. Bacon's Castle's fireball is told in many versions without named witnesses, and a 1950 novel already featured it. The Squire's Castle legend says the wife died in the building, but the record of her death places it in Wickliffe.
Some accounts come from people tied to the site: the Waverly Hills statements come from its co-owners and paid tour staff, so we count them as one origin, and the Conrad-Caldwell descendant was giving a tour.
By the dates they describe, the reports run from the 1895 Moonville item through the early 1970s at Bachelor's Grove and the 1992 lighthouse sighting, but most sources we found were published from 2009 onward, in news features, ghost roundups and tour pages.
Orbs in photographs and video are camera output, not accounts of an experience, and unattributed mentions of orbs, as at Fort Monroe, Old Fort Niagara and the Hunting Island Lighthouse, do not count toward a rating.
How we rate these stories
We count an account when we can see who saw the light and where they first described it. A legend repeated by many sources counts once. Read more in our methodology and the evidence report.
Notable places in this guide
The best-documented places the guide draws on. Each page has the full history, every account we traced and the sources.

Former asylum · Louisville, KY
Waverly Hills Sanatorium
Shadowy figures in the long corridors, described by tour staff, a ghost-story writer and a TV investigation team.
Well DocumentedTours only
Tunnel · OH
Moonville Tunnel
Moonville Tunnel is an 1850s railroad tunnel in Zaleski State Forest, all that remains with a small cemetery of a vanished coal settlement.
Documented AccountsOutside only
Historic house · VA
Bacon's Castle
Bacon's Castle is Virginia's oldest documented house, built in 1665 by current dating (older sources say about 1655) and seized by Bacon's rebels in 1676; its 19th-century owners, the Hankins family, enslaved people there.
Documented AccountsTours only
All 24 places in this guide
Forest
The Paulding Light
Michigan
Tunnel
Moonville Tunnel
Ohio
Historic house
Squire's Castle
Willoughby Hills, Ohio
Historic house
Bacon's Castle
Virginia
Bridge
Poinsett Bridge
South Carolina
Bridge
Old Alton Bridge
Texas
Road
Gore Orphanage Road
Ohio
Lighthouse
Old Presque Isle Lighthouse
Presque Isle Harbor, Michigan
Historic house
LaLaurie Mansion
New Orleans, Louisiana
Cave
Mammoth Cave National Park
Kentucky
Museum
Jesse James Farm and Museum
Missouri
Historic house
White Hall State Historic Site
Kentucky
Cemetery
Bellefontaine Cemetery
St. Louis, Missouri
Former asylum
Waverly Hills Sanatorium
Louisville, Kentucky
Former asylum
Eloise
Westland, Michigan
Historic house
Conrad-Caldwell House Museum
Louisville, Kentucky
Fort
Fort Concho National Historic Landmark
San Angelo, Texas
Cemetery
Bachelor's Grove Cemetery
Illinois
Cemetery
Cave Hill Cemetery
Louisville, Kentucky
Former asylum
The Ridges (former Athens Lunatic Asylum)
Athens, Ohio
Cemetery
Boothill Graveyard
Tombstone, Arizona
Fort
Fort Monroe National Monument
Hampton, Virginia
Fort
Old Fort Niagara
New York
Lighthouse
Hunting Island Lighthouse
South Carolina
Written from our published research and reviewed by the editor. Send a correction.















