Haunted Places USA

← Tombstone Bird Cage Theatre

TheaterArizona

Bird Cage Theatre

History, the owners' stories and a 2006 TV investigation

Tombstone, Arizona

The Bird Cage Theatre is an 1881 variety theater, saloon and dance hall on Tombstone's Allen Street, now a privately run museum.

What do we know about Bird Cage Theatre?

Much else repeated about the building, including counts of ghosts and the 1921 schoolchildren story, has no source we could trace. The investigators' audio and video results are device output and are not counted as accounts.

Documented Accounts

Our rating of the reports about Bird Cage Theatre: Documented Accounts. At least one traceable published or first-hand account of an unexplained experience. We check that the reports exist, not the supernatural. The rating describes the evidence for the reports, not whether the place is haunted.

Reported accounts
2
Counted for the rating
1
Research sources
6

Counted for the rating: independent accounts we could trace to a witness. Retellings of the same story count once, and staff passing on what visitors said aren’t counted. How we count

Reported experiences don’t establish a supernatural cause.

Read our evidence assessment →
Open to visitorsPaid entryVisitor information →

The hauntings

Accounts, encounters and stories associated with Bird Cage Theatre.

What has been reported?

  • Moving objects
  • Apparitions
  • Smells
  • Voices
  • Music
  • Footsteps
  • Shadow figures

Phenomena described in accounts associated with this location — not independently verified events.

Reported experiences

2 published and reported accounts, each assessed by its source.

  • Account 01 · February 2026 · 2 versions

    The owning Hunley family and staff, 2026

    Stories credited to the owning family and staff say a gaming table weighing several hundred pounds was found moved overnight in front of a door bearing a sign about the building's '26 Resident Ghosts', that the hat of a Wyatt Earp figure was repeatedly found knocked…

    • Moving objects
    • Apparitions
    • Smells
    • Voices
    • Music
    Published accountReported by The owning Hunley family and staff, as retold by Legends of America

    Note: Published by a ghost-history website without dates or the name of any witness; we found no account by the family themselves.

    Read full account ›

    Stories credited to the owning family and staff say a gaming table weighing several hundred pounds was found moved overnight in front of a door bearing a sign about the building's '26 Resident Ghosts', that the hat of a Wyatt Earp figure was repeatedly found knocked to the floor, and that a missing antique poker chip reappeared on a table and later in a locked drawer.[5]

    Staff and visitors are said to have seen a man in a visor and 1800s clothes crossing the stage, and to have heard laughter, music and a woman singing, and smelled cigar smoke and whiskey.[5]

    Note: No named witness or date; the source gives no origin for these reports.

    View source 5

  • Account 02 · 2006 · 2 versions

    Jason Hawes and Grant Wilson, 2006

    Jason Hawes and Grant Wilson of the Ghost Hunters series, investigating on June 23, 2006, each described a full-length figure of a woman in white wearing a bonnet, and also reported a dark shadow crossing a window and sounds like bootsteps and shuffling cards.[6]

    • Apparitions
    • Footsteps
    • Shadow figures
    • Music
    • Moving objects
    Published accountReported by Jason Hawes and Grant Wilson (Ghost Hunters), via The Tombstone News

    Note: Reported by the local paper from the broadcast and the visit; the two investigators were filming together, so we count them as one origin.

    Read full account ›

    Jason Hawes and Grant Wilson of the Ghost Hunters series, investigating on June 23, 2006, each described a full-length figure of a woman in white wearing a bonnet, and also reported a dark shadow crossing a window and sounds like bootsteps and shuffling cards.[6]

    On the same investigation, two other team members heard a noise and found that a power cord they had wrapped around an old fire bell had come loose; their video showed it uncoiling and falling, and an audio recording picked up 'old time' music they had not heard at the time.[6]

    Note: The video and audio are device output and are not counted as accounts of an experience.

    View source 6

Legends & disputed stories

Stories told about the place that the records don’t confirm.

  • Legend

    A story holds that in 1921, when a school was built across the street, students heard laughter and music from the empty building and smelled cigar smoke; the operator also promotes a 'Lady in White' hallway backstage.[5][2]


    What the research shows: We found no source for the 1921 story; the 'Lady in White' hallway is the operator's marketing.

Before you go

Planning a visit?

Location

535 E Allen St, Tombstone, AZ 85638

Get directions

Open to visitors

Parts of the inside are open to the public.

Access details ›

The building is a privately run museum with paid self-guided entry and paid nightly ghost tours; check the official site for times. The ghost tours are a paid attraction, and we do not treat the operator's marketing as evidence.

Entry

Paid entry

Access last checked November 17, 2026. Confirm times and prices before you travel.

The history of Bird Cage Theatre

The Bird Cage Theatre is an 1881 variety theater, saloon and dance hall on Tombstone's Allen Street, now a privately run museum. Its ghost stories come from the owning family and staff, retold by Legends of America, and from the Ghost Hunters team, who said in 2006 that they both saw a woman in white. It is open to paying visitors and sells nightly ghost tours.

Established
1881
Also known as
Bird Cage Theater

A theater for the other side of town

The Bird Cage opened on Allen Street in December 1881, run by Lottie and William "Billy" Hutchinson. The operator gives December 26; the Bisbee Mining and Historical Museum gives December 23. The National Park Service's 1978 landmark nomination for Tombstone describes it as a combination theater and dance hall for "less reputable" shows, in contrast to Schieffelin Hall, and presumes its name came from the curtained boxes hung from the ceiling, where women who worked there met customers. The Hutchinsons sold to Hugh McCrum and John Stroufe, who sold in January 1886 to Joe Bignon and his wife. The theater closed as Tombstone's mines flooded and silver prices fell; the museum dates the closing to 1889, the operator to 1892.

The building stored furniture from 1900 to 1928, reopened for the first Helldorado celebration in 1929, and later served as a coffee shop and a souvenir shop. The Hunley family owned it for much of the 20th century; Bill Hunley, who inherited it from his grandmother, died in November 2021.

The owners' and staff stories

Legends of America credits the owning family and staff with several stories: a heavy gaming table found moved overnight in front of a door with a sign about the building's "26 Resident Ghosts", a hat repeatedly knocked off a Wyatt Earp figure, and a missing poker chip that turned up again. Staff and visitors are also said to have seen a man in a visor crossing the stage and heard laughter, music and singing. None of these accounts is dated or signed. The operator's own site now speaks of a "Lady in White" hallway backstage.

Ghost Hunters, 2006

The Tombstone News reported that Jason Hawes and Grant Wilson of the Ghost Hunters series visited on June 23, 2006, and that both described a full-length figure of a woman in white wearing a bonnet, along with a shadow crossing a window and sounds like footsteps and shuffling cards. Their audio recording picked up "old time" music and a video showed a cord on a fire bell uncoiling; we record these, but they are device output and we do not count them.

What we could not trace

The story that schoolchildren across the street heard music and smelled cigar smoke in 1921 appears without a source.

Source: Frederick D. Nichols, Historic American Buildings Survey (November 1937), Public domain (US government work; Library of Congress: no known restrictions on images made by the U.S. Government)

Through the years

  1. 1881

    1881

    The National Park Service's landmark nomination describes the 1881 building as a combined theater and dance hall for the town's less respectable shows, in contrast to Schieffelin Hall, and presumes its name came from the curtained boxes hung…

    Read more ›

    The National Park Service's landmark nomination describes the 1881 building as a combined theater and dance hall for the town's less respectable shows, in contrast to Schieffelin Hall, and presumes its name came from the curtained boxes hung from the ceiling, where women who worked there met customers.[3]

    Caveat: The nomination states the origin of the name as a presumption.

  2. 1881

    Bird Cage opens

    The Bird Cage opened on Allen Street in December 1881, owned by Lottie and William 'Billy' Hutchinson.[1][2]

    Caveat: The operator gives December 26, 1881; the Bisbee Mining and Historical Museum gives December 23.

  3. 1886

    Sold to Joe Bignon

    The Hutchinsons sold the theater to Hugh McCrum and John Stroufe, who sold it in January 1886 to Joe Bignon and his wife; Bignon renamed it the Elite Theatre.[1][2]

  4. 1889–1892

    Theater closes

    The theater closed as Tombstone's mines flooded and silver prices fell.[1][2]

    Caveat: The Bisbee museum dates the closing to 1889; the operator to 1892.

  5. 1929

    Reopens for the first Helldorado

    The building stored furniture from 1900 to 1928, reopened as a theater for Tombstone's first Helldorado celebration in 1929, and later served as a coffee shop and a souvenir shop before becoming a museum.[1][3]

  6. 2021

    Death of owner Bill Hunley

    The Hunley family owned the Bird Cage for much of the 20th century; Bill Hunley, who inherited it on his grandmother's death, died on November 12, 2021.[4]

The research conclusion

Why it has this rating

One traceable account: Ghost Hunters investigators Jason Hawes and Grant Wilson, filming together in 2006, both described a woman in white wearing a bonnet. Stories credited to the owning family and staff name no witness and are not counted, and audio and video results aren't counted, so this is Documented Accounts.

Read our methodology →Assessed November 17, 2026 by Richard Pryn
Read the full written assessment ›

The building's 1880s history is documented by the National Park Service's landmark nomination, a regional museum and the operator, though they disagree on when it opened and closed. The ghost reputation is traceable to two origins: stories credited to the owning family and staff, which we found only in a ghost-history website with no dates, and the Ghost Hunters investigators, whose 2006 visit the local paper reported.

Much else repeated about the building, including counts of ghosts and the 1921 schoolchildren story, has no source we could trace. The investigators' audio and video results are device output and are not counted as accounts.

The sources behind the story

6 research references support this entry.

  1. 1Bisbee Mining & Historical Museum1981.194.21 PC (Bird Cage Theater collection item) Website · Reference 01

    1981.194.21 PC (Bird Cage Theater collection item). Bisbee Mining & Historical Museum.

    Regional museum's catalog description: opened December 23, 1881; owned by the Hutchinsons, sold to McCrum and Stroufe, who sold in January 1886 to Joe Bignon and his wife; closed 1889; furniture storage 1900–1928; reopened for the first Helldorado in 1929; coffee shop in the 1930s, later a souvenir shop. Undated and unsourced; differs from the operator on the opening and closing dates.

    Accessed November 17, 2026.

    View original source →

  2. 2Bird Cage TheatreBird Cage Theatre (official site, history and 'Paranormal Hotspots' pages) Official or site history · Reference 02

    Bird Cage Theatre (official site, history and 'Paranormal Hotspots' pages). Bird Cage Theatre, 2026.

    Operator's site: opened December 26, 1881; owners Lottie and William 'Billy' Hutchinson, then Hugh McCrum and John Stroufe; Bignon renamed it the Elite Theatre; closed 1892 after the mines flooded and silver fell; sells self-guided entry and ghost tours. Its ghost pages ('Lady In White' hallway, apparitions on stairs) are the operator's marketing, not evidence, and its history pages cite no sources.

    Accessed November 17, 2026.

    View original source →

  3. 3National Park Service, Historic Sites Survey DivisionNational Register of Historic Places Inventory - Nomination Form: Tombstone (National Historic Landmark district) Register or nomination · Reference 03

    Marilyn Larew, National Register of Historic Places Inventory - Nomination Form: Tombstone (National Historic Landmark district). National Park Service, Historic Sites Survey Division, 1978-02.

    Federal landmark nomination (prepared February 1978; district designated an NHL in 1961). Item 7 lists the Bird Cage Theater (1881) as a three-bay building that 'once hosted the less reputable stage presentations, as a combination theater and dance hall', presumes the name came from curtained boxes, and says it is now a museum. Item 8 contrasts it with Schieffelin Hall. Says nothing about ghosts. Read from the scanned PDF's text layer.

    Accessed November 17, 2026.

    View original source →

  4. 4The Tombstone NewsTombstone Loses A Legend: William (Bill) Hunley Newspaper · Reference 04

    Tombstone Loses A Legend: William (Bill) Hunley. The Tombstone News, 2021-11.

    Obituary: Bill Hunley (born January 7, 1941) died November 12, 2021; his grandparents owned the Bird Cage and he inherited it on his grandmother's death (year not given). Reports no ghost experience of his own.

    Accessed November 17, 2026.

    View original source →

  5. 5Legends of AmericaGhosts of Tombstone, Arizona Website · Reference 05

    Kathy Alexander, Ghosts of Tombstone, Arizona. Legends of America, 2026-02.

    Ghost-history website (updated February 2026; first publication date not given). Credits the owning Hunley family and staff with the moved table, the Earp figure's hat and the poker chip stories, and unnamed staff and visitors with the visored man, music, laughter and cigar smoke; also tells the 1921 schoolchildren story. Cites no sources and gives no dates for the experiences; used only as the place these stories were published.

    Accessed November 17, 2026.

    View original source →

  6. 6The Tombstone NewsThe Birdcage; It's Definitely Haunted Newspaper · Reference 06

    Meredith Littlejohn, The Birdcage; It's Definitely Haunted. The Tombstone News, 2006.

    Local paper's report of the Ghost Hunters (TAPS) investigation on June 23 and its fall-season broadcast: Jason Hawes and Grant Wilson each described a woman in white with a bonnet; two other investigators heard a noise and found a cord fallen from a fire bell, later seen uncoiling on video; an audio recording picked up music. Names the general manager and two employees, whom we do not name. The page shows no date; the 2006 year is inferred from the broadcast and an image file name.

    Accessed November 17, 2026.

    View original source →

All our sources