← Presque Isle Harbor Old Presque Isle Lighthouse
Old Presque Isle Lighthouse
An 1840 harbor light and the glow in its tower
Presque Isle Harbor, Michigan
Old Presque Isle Lighthouse is an 1840 harbor light on Lake Huron, retired in 1871 and now a township museum.
What do we know about Old Presque Isle Lighthouse?
The haunting rests on one traceable account, the lighthouse caretaker's sighting of a light in May 1992, known here only as retold by Lighthouse Friends. Later sightings by residents, mariners and staff are unattributed, and the girl who met 'the man in the tower' is a local legend. Reflections in the lantern glass are a plausible explanation, and the museum society itself puts little stock in the stories.
Our rating of the reports about Old Presque Isle Lighthouse: Documented Accounts. At least one traceable published or first-hand account of an unexplained experience. We check that the reports exist, not the supernatural. The rating describes the evidence for the reports, not whether the place is haunted.
- Reported accounts
- 2
- Counted for the rating
- 1
- Research sources
- 6
Counted for the rating: independent accounts we could trace to a witness. Retellings of the same story count once, and staff passing on what visitors said aren’t counted. How we count
Reported experiences don’t establish a supernatural cause.
Read our evidence assessment →The hauntings
Accounts, encounters and stories associated with Old Presque Isle Lighthouse.
What has been reported?
- Phantom lights
- Apparitions
- Voices
Phenomena described in accounts associated with this location — not independently verified events.
Reported experiences
2 published and reported accounts, each assessed by its source.
Account 01
The lighthouse caretaker
The lighthouse caretaker said that in May 1992, a few months after her husband's death, she was driving back from dinner at her daughter's house when she saw a light glowing at the top of the tower, though she knew the lamp had been disconnected years…
- Phantom lights
Published accountReported by The lighthouse caretaker (as retold by Lighthouse Friends)Note: Retold by Lighthouse Friends, which also notes that others put the glow down to distant lights reflecting in the lantern glass. The earliest printing could not be accessed (probably the 1994 Knight-Ridder article in its references).
Read full account ›
The lighthouse caretaker said that in May 1992, a few months after her husband's death, she was driving back from dinner at her daughter's house when she saw a light glowing at the top of the tower, though she knew the lamp had been disconnected years before; she later said it was George's way of keeping the lighthouse's spirit alive.[1]
Account 02 · October 1, 2017
A longtime lighthouse guide, 2017
A 2017 magazine feature said local residents, mariners, lighthouse staff and the Coast Guard have seen the light in the unpowered tower, usually in storms, and that the Coast Guard has inspected the tower several times; a longtime guide said people caught in storms in small…
- Phantom lights
No traceable witnessReported by A longtime lighthouse guide (Michigan Blue, 2017)Note: No witness is named; the guide relays others' stories rather than her own experience. No Coast Guard record of an inspection was found.
Read full account ›
A 2017 magazine feature said local residents, mariners, lighthouse staff and the Coast Guard have seen the light in the unpowered tower, usually in storms, and that the Coast Guard has inspected the tower several times; a longtime guide said people caught in storms in small boats swear the light brought them into the harbor.[4]
Legends & disputed stories
Stories told about the place that the records don’t confirm.
- Legend
A local story says a girl who climbed the tower came down saying she had been talking to "the man in the tower," and later picked out George Parris from his portrait in the cottage.[5]
What the research shows: The girl, her family and the date are not given.
Before you go
Planning a visit?
Open to visitors
Parts of the inside are open to the public.
Access details ›
Run by Presque Isle Township and its museum society as a seasonal museum and park; the tower can be climbed for a fee, weather permitting. The lighthouses closed for the winter after the 2026 season and are due to reopen in 2027; check the society's site for dates.
Entry
Paid entry
Access last checked November 16, 2026. Confirm times and prices before you travel.
Approximate location, within about 1 km.
The history of Old Presque Isle Lighthouse
Old Presque Isle Lighthouse is an 1840 harbor light on Lake Huron, retired in 1871 and now a township museum. Its ghost story centers on a light in the unpowered tower: the lighthouse caretaker said she saw it in May 1992, months after her husband George died. Others say reflections explain the glow. The museum is open in season and the tower can be climbed for a fee.
- Established
- 1840
- Also known as
- Old Presque Isle Light
An 1840 harbor light
In July 1838 Congress set aside $5,000 for a light to guide ships into Presque Isle harbor on Lake Huron. Detroit builder Jeremiah Moors took the contract in 1839, and the small tower of stone and brick, about 30 feet tall, was finished in 1840. Henry Woolsey became its first keeper that September.
The light served only about three decades. In 1871 a taller Presque Isle light a mile to the north took over, the old lantern and lens were removed, and the last keeper, Patrick Garrity Sr., moved to the new station.
Private hands and a new lantern
The government auctioned the station in 1897. It later passed to the Stebbins family, who rebuilt the keeper's house around 1939 and in 1961 put a replica lantern room with a surplus Fresnel lens on top of the tower. The lighthouse was placed on the Michigan Register in 1964 and the National Register in 1973. In 1977 a retired couple, George Parris and his wife, were hired to run it as caretakers and guides. Presque Isle Township bought the lighthouse in 1995 and runs it as a park and museum.
The light in the tower
George Parris died in January 1992. As Lighthouse Friends tells it, in May that year his widow, the lighthouse caretaker, was driving home from dinner at her daughter's house when she saw a light glowing at the top of the tower, though the lamp had been disconnected years before. She came to see it as George's way of keeping the lighthouse's spirit alive. Others have put the glow down to distant lights reflecting in the lantern glass.
A 2017 magazine feature said residents, mariners and staff have also seen the light, usually in storms, and a longtime guide said boaters credit it with bringing them into the harbor, but no witness was named. A 2006 local newspaper story adds a legend that a girl who climbed the tower talked with "the man in the tower" and later picked out George Parris from his portrait.
The museum society itself acknowledges the rumors but says it places no great stock in them.
Through the years
1840
Lighthouse completed
1977
Parris couple become caretakers
In 1977 the owner hired a retired couple, George Parris and his wife, to run the lighthouse as caretakers and guides; George Parris died in January 1992.[1]
Also recorded
The museum society's own history page acknowledges persistent rumors that the Old Light is haunted, but says the society places no great stock in them.[3]
The research conclusion
Why it has this rating
One traceable account: the caretaker's 1992 sighting of a light in a tower with no working lamp, retold by Lighthouse Friends. Later sightings are unattributed, and reflections in the lantern glass are a plausible explanation.
Read the full written assessment ›
The history is solid: the museum society, a detailed lighthouse-history site and the National Register record agree on the 1840 construction, the 1871 retirement and the 1995 township purchase, differing only on the exact day in July 1838 when the money was set aside.
The haunting rests on one traceable account, the lighthouse caretaker's sighting of a light in May 1992, known here only as retold by Lighthouse Friends. Later sightings by residents, mariners and staff are unattributed, and the girl who met 'the man in the tower' is a local legend. Reflections in the lantern glass are a plausible explanation, and the museum society itself puts little stock in the stories.
The sources behind the story
6 research references support this entry.
1Lighthouse FriendsPresque Isle (Old) Lighthouse, Michigan Website · Reference 01
Presque Isle (Old) Lighthouse, Michigan. Lighthouse Friends.
Detailed lighthouse-history site drawing on Lighthouse Board records; its reference list includes a 1994 Knight-Ridder article and a 1998 Lighthouse Digest article that we could not access. Gives the 1977 hiring of George Parris and his wife, George's death in January 1992 and his widow's account of the light, with a short quote. Gives the appropriation as July 7, 1838 (the society says July 5). Undated.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
2National Park Service, NPGalleryOld Presque Isle Lighthouse (NRIS 73000957) Register or nomination · Reference 02
Old Presque Isle Lighthouse (NRIS 73000957). National Park Service, NPGallery, 1973-04-11.
National Register record metadata: significant years 1839, 1840 and 1871; architect Jeremiah Moors; location 'Presque Isle; Off SR 405'. The nomination PDF has not been digitized ('not yet digitized' placeholder), so only the metadata was read.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
3Presque Isle Township Museum SocietyOld Presque Isle Lighthouse (1840) Official or site history · Reference 03
Old Presque Isle Lighthouse (1840). Presque Isle Township Museum Society.
Operating museum society's history page, checked 2026-11-16. Gives the 1838 appropriation (July 5), the 1839 contract with Jeremiah Moors, completion in 1840, first keeper Henry Woolsey, the 1871 replacement, owners, the 1961 lantern, register listings and the 1995 township purchase. Mentions 'persistent rumors' of a haunting but says the society places no great stock in them. Says the tower can be climbed for a modest fee.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
4Michigan Blue MagazineSpooky Lights Magazine · Reference 04
Marla R. Miller, Spooky Lights. Michigan Blue Magazine, 2017-10-01.
Regional magazine feature on haunted Michigan lighthouses. Says the tower was de-electrified in 1979 and that residents, mariners, staff and the Coast Guard have seen a light, without naming any of them, and quotes a longtime guide relaying boaters' stories.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
5Presque Isle County AdvanceThe strange sightings and sounds at the 40 Mile Point Lighthouse Newspaper · Reference 05
Editor, The strange sightings and sounds at the 40 Mile Point Lighthouse. Presque Isle County Advance, 2006-10-26.
Local weekly newspaper story mainly about 40 Mile Point. Calls the Old Presque Isle haunting 'legendary' and gives the story of a girl who identified 'the man in the tower' from a portrait of George Parris. No witness is named.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
6Presque Isle Township Museum SocietyHours Official or site history · Reference 06
Hours. Presque Isle Township Museum Society.
Checked 2026-11-16: says the Old and New lighthouses and the 1905 Keeper's House have closed for the winter after the 2026 season and will reopen in 2027. Gives no fees.
Accessed November 16, 2026.

















