Haunted Places USA

← Ohio Gore Orphanage Road

RoadOhio

Gore Orphanage Road

The legend and the history

Ohio

Gore Orphanage Road near Vermilion is known for a legend that children died in an orphanage fire and their cries can still be heard.

What do we know about Gore Orphanage Road?

The reported experiences (screams, mists and lights) come from paranormal groups and authors visiting a site already famous for the legend, so they are not independent of it.

Documented Accounts

Our rating of the reports about Gore Orphanage Road: Documented Accounts. At least one traceable published or first-hand account of an unexplained experience. We check that the reports exist, not the supernatural. The rating describes the evidence for the reports, not whether the place is haunted.

Reported accounts
2
Counted for the rating
1
Research sources
4

Counted for the rating: independent accounts we could trace to a witness. Retellings of the same story count once, and staff passing on what visitors said aren’t counted. How we count

Reported experiences don’t establish a supernatural cause.

Read our evidence assessment →
Access not confirmedWe haven’t confirmed whether visitors are allowed.Visitor information →

The hauntings

Accounts, encounters and stories associated with Gore Orphanage Road.

What has been reported?

  • Voices
  • Apparitions
  • Phantom lights

Phenomena described in accounts associated with this location — not independently verified events.

Reported experiences

2 published and reported accounts, each assessed by its source.

  • Account 01 · 2009

    North Ohio Paranormal Scientific Society, 2009

    The North Ohio Paranormal Scientific Society said all four members of its team heard a loud scream during a September 2009 investigation.[3]

    • Voices
    Published accountReported by North Ohio Paranormal Scientific Society

    Note: The group visited because of the legend.

    Read full account ›

    The North Ohio Paranormal Scientific Society said all four members of its team heard a loud scream during a September 2009 investigation.[3]

    View source 3

  • Account 02 · 1999–2012

    Tom Ogden, 1999–2012

    Published authors and investigators have described ghost children at the ruins (Tom Ogden, 1999), local claims of filmed ghostly children (John Petkovic, 2003), and mists, lights and a glowing object on video (Joseph Horodyski, 2012).[1]

    • Apparitions
    • Phantom lights
    Published accountReported by Tom Ogden, John Petkovic and Joseph Horodyski, as summarized by Josh Hunt

    Note: Known to us only through Josh Hunt's summary; the original publications were not consulted. Hunt disputes Horodyski's interpretation.

    Read full account ›

    Published authors and investigators have described ghost children at the ruins (Tom Ogden, 1999), local claims of filmed ghostly children (John Petkovic, 2003), and mists, lights and a glowing object on video (Joseph Horodyski, 2012).[1]

    View source 1

Legends & disputed stories

Stories told about the place that the records don’t confirm.

  • Legend

    The legend says an orphanage on the road burned with children trapped inside and that their cries can still be heard; writers suggest it merged the orphanage, the Wilber family's losses and the memory of the Collinwood fire.[1][2]


    What the research shows: Not supported by the documented history.

Before you go

Can I visit?

Location

Ohio

Access not confirmed

We haven’t confirmed whether visitors are allowed.

Access details ›

Gore Orphanage Road is a public road near Vermilion, but the remains of the Swift mansion and the orphanage lie in woods off the road and cannot be seen from it. We could not confirm who owns these sites today, so treat them as private land: stay on the public road and do not enter posted or wooded property.

Access last checked November 19, 2026.

Please visit responsibly

This place isn’t open to visitors. Don’t trespass: view it from public land, or learn about it from local museums and archives.

The history of Gore Orphanage Road

Gore Orphanage Road near Vermilion is known for a legend that children died in an orphanage fire and their cries can still be heard. The history is different: a real orphanage operated nearby from 1902 to 1916, but no deadly fire is recorded there; the ruins are of the Swift mansion, which burned empty in 1923. Paranormal groups report screams and lights. The road is public, but the sites may be private land.

Established
Swift mansion mid-1800s; Light of Hope Orphanage 1902–1916
Also known as
Gore Orphanage

A road named for a gore and an orphanage

Gore Orphanage Road runs through the countryside near Vermilion, crossing the Vermilion River. Its name has two parts. "Gore" comes from a surveying error that left a narrow strip of land, shaped like the gore of a dress. "Orphanage" refers to the Light of Hope Orphanage, which Rev. Johann Sprunger and his wife Katharina opened on Gore Road in 1902 on a 543-acre site.

The real orphanage

At its height the orphanage housed up to about 120 children. Former residents complained of mistreatment, poor food and neglect, and a 1909 investigation found that Ohio had no laws regulating such homes. The orphanage closed in July 1916. Part of its buildings later burned and the rest were torn down; one house from the Sprunger property survives.

The Swift mansion

The ruins usually pointed out as "Gore Orphanage" belong to a different place: the mansion Joseph Swift built in the mid-1800s, in the area known as Swift's Hollow. It later belonged to Nicholas Wilber, a Spiritualist whose family lost four children to diphtheria and held seances. The mansion was abandoned in 1901, was never used by the orphanage, and burned in December 1923, probably set by vandals.

Where the fire story comes from

The legend says an orphanage burned with children trapped inside. No such fire is recorded at the Light of Hope Orphanage or the Swift mansion. A real school fire did kill many children: on March 4, 1908, Lakeview Elementary School in Collinwood, now part of Cleveland, burned, and 172 children and 2 teachers died, according to the Encyclopedia of Cleveland History; the Vermilion Chamber of Commerce gives 176 children. Writers have suggested that the memory of Collinwood became attached to Gore Orphanage Road, along with the Wilber family's grief and seances.

What people report

Visitors and paranormal groups describe screams, mists and lights. In September 2009 the North Ohio Paranormal Scientific Society said all four members of its team heard a loud scream. Other authors and investigators have published reports of ghostly children and a glowing object on video. All of these accounts come from people who arrived knowing the legend.

Source: JoshH21, CC BY-SA 3.0

Through the years

  1. 1800

    Swift mansion built

    Joseph Swift built a mansion in the area known as Swift's Hollow in the mid-1800s.[2]

    Caveat: Exact construction years not confirmed from a source we consulted.

  2. 1902

    Light of Hope Orphanage opens

    Rev. Johann Sprunger and his wife Katharina founded the Light of Hope Orphanage on Gore Road in 1902, on a 543-acre site; it housed up to about 120 children at a time.[1][2]

    Caveat: The Chamber page gives no sources for these figures.

  3. 1908

    Collinwood school fire (elsewhere)

    On March 4, 1908, Lakeview Elementary School in Collinwood, now part of Cleveland, burned; 172 children and 2 teachers died, according to the Encyclopedia of Cleveland History (the Vermilion Chamber gives 176 children).[4]

    Caveat: This happened in the Cleveland area, not on Gore Orphanage Road.

  4. 1909

    Investigation into the orphanage

    Former residents alleged mistreatment, poor food and neglect, and a 1909 investigation found Ohio had no laws regulating such institutions.[2]

  5. 1916

    Orphanage closes

    The orphanage closed in July 1916; part of its buildings later burned and the rest were torn down, with one house from the property surviving.[2]

  6. 1923

    Swift mansion burns

    The Swift mansion was abandoned in 1901, was never used by the orphanage, and burned in December 1923, probably set by vandals.[3][2]

    Caveat: The Chamber says 'late 1923'; NOPSS says December 1923.

Also recorded

  • The 'Gore' in the road's name comes from a surveying error that left a narrow strip of land, and 'Orphanage' refers to the nearby Light of Hope Orphanage.[1][2]

  • The mansion later belonged to Nicholas Wilber, a Spiritualist; the Wilber family lost four children to diphtheria and held seances.[1][2]

    Caveat: Where and when the children died is not stated in the sources opened; see notes.

  • No record has been found of children dying in a fire at the Light of Hope Orphanage or at Swift's Hollow; a Lorain County Historical Society archivist told an investigator there was no 'Gore Orphanage' at all.[1][2]

The research conclusion

Why it has this rating

One traceable account: all four members of the North Ohio Paranormal Scientific Society's team said they heard a loud scream during their September 2009 investigation. The authors summarized by a skeptical writer describe ghost children, local claims of filmed children and video of lights without a traceable witness, so they aren't counted, and this is Documented Accounts. The orphanage-fire legend has no supporting record.

Read our methodology →Assessed November 17, 2026 by Richard Pryn
Read the full written assessment ›

The documented history does not support the legend. The Light of Hope Orphanage was real, and former residents complained of poor treatment, but the Vermilion Chamber of Commerce says there is no proof that anyone died at the orphanage or at Swift's Hollow, and a skeptical investigation found no record of a fire that killed orphans. The ruin people visit is the Swift mansion, never part of the orphanage. The children-in-a-fire motif closely resembles the 1908 Collinwood school fire in the Cleveland area, and writers have suggested the legend borrowed from it.

The reported experiences (screams, mists and lights) come from paranormal groups and authors visiting a site already famous for the legend, so they are not independent of it.

The sources behind the story

4 research references support this entry.

  1. 1Skeptical Briefs (Center for Inquiry / Skeptical Inquirer)The Gore Orphanage Hauntings Magazine · Reference 01

    Josh Hunt, The Gore Orphanage Hauntings. Skeptical Briefs (Center for Inquiry / Skeptical Inquirer), 2013-02-11.

    Skeptical investigation drawing on the Lorain County Historical Society and Metro Parks staff; found no evidence of a deadly orphanage fire. Also summarizes published ghost reports (Ogden 1999, Petkovic 2003, Horodyski 2012), which we have not consulted.

    Accessed November 16, 2026.

    View original source →

  2. 2Vermilion Chamber of CommerceGore Orphanage Website · Reference 02

    Gore Orphanage. Vermilion Chamber of Commerce.

    Local civic summary of the history and legend; clear on what is legend. No author or citations given, so specific dates (1902 founding, 1909 investigation, July 1916 closure, 1923 fire) should be checked against contemporary newspapers. Silent on current ownership.

    Accessed November 16, 2026.

    View original source →

  3. 3North Ohio Paranormal Scientific SocietyGore Orphanage Website · Reference 03

    Gore Orphanage. North Ohio Paranormal Scientific Society, 2009.

    Paranormal group's investigation page. Cited only as the place its team's September 2009 report was published; its history section is uncited.

    Accessed November 16, 2026.

    View original source →

  4. 4Encyclopedia of Cleveland History, Case Western Reserve UniversityCollinwood School Fire Website · Reference 04

    Collinwood School Fire. Encyclopedia of Cleveland History, Case Western Reserve University.

    Authoritative account of the 1908 Collinwood fire; cites Badal (2020) and the 1908 Complete Story of the Collinwood Disaster. Says nothing about Gore Orphanage Road.

    Accessed November 16, 2026.

    View original source →

All our sources

Written by Haunted Places USA research. Ratings reviewed by Richard Pryn.

Facts last checked November 16, 2026. First published November 16, 2026. Updated November 17, 2026. Rated under our research methodology.

Spotted a mistake or have a source we should see? Send a correction.