← New Albany Culbertson Mansion
Culbertson Mansion
State Historic Site
New Albany, Indiana
Culbertson Mansion is a Second Empire house built just after the Civil War for William S. Culbertson, one of Indiana's wealthiest men, and now a state historic site.
What do we know about Culbertson Mansion?
The ghost accounts come almost entirely from people connected with the site: a former employee who led ghost tours, unnamed staff and volunteers, and guests at paid overnight fundraisers. They are traceable but not independent.
Our rating of the reports about Culbertson Mansion: Documented Accounts. At least one traceable published or first-hand account of an unexplained experience. We check that the reports exist, not the supernatural. The rating describes the evidence for the reports, not whether the place is haunted.
- Reported accounts
- 2
- Counted for the rating
- 1
- Research sources
- 8
Counted for the rating: independent accounts we could trace to a witness. Retellings of the same story count once, and staff passing on what visitors said aren’t counted. How we count
Reported experiences don’t establish a supernatural cause.
Read our evidence assessment →The hauntings
Accounts, encounters and stories associated with Culbertson Mansion.
What has been reported?
- Apparitions
- Voices
- Smells
- Electrical
- Moving objects
- Shadow figures
Phenomena described in accounts associated with this location — not independently verified events.
Reported experiences
2 published and reported accounts, each assessed by its source.
Account 01 · October 26, 2009 · 3 versions
The Horizon, 2009
A former employee who led ghost tours and headed the Friends of Culbertson Mansion, said she had heard whistling while alone on a floor, seen a female figure pass the door while cleaning a parlor, and heard a man's voice say "shhh"; she said she had…
- Apparitions
- Voices
- Electrical
- Moving objects
- Shadow figures
Published accountReported by A former employee and head of the Friends of Culbertson Mansion, to The Horizon (2009)Note: Connected to the site and its ghost tours.
Read full account ›
A former employee who led ghost tours and headed the Friends of Culbertson Mansion, said she had heard whistling while alone on a floor, seen a female figure pass the door while cleaning a parlor, and heard a man's voice say "shhh"; she said she had never felt threatened.[3]
The same former employee also said that a police officer who answered an alarm with her found nothing inside but saw a woman in a gray dress on the back veranda as he approached.[3]
The county tourism bureau says staff and volunteers have reported electrical problems, figures moving between rooms, sounds after hours and missing items, and that some have refused to work in the Carriage House.[5]
Note: Second-hand; the officer is not named.
Note: Unnamed; published to promote the haunted-house fundraiser.
Account 02 · September 2008
Indiana Daily Student, 2008
Guests at a paid overnight stay in 2008 described flickering lights, a smell of tobacco where no one was smoking, and a child's handprint appearing on a bedspread.[4]
- Smells
- Electrical
Published accountReported by Unnamed overnight guests, per the Indiana Daily Student (2008), drawing on the Courier-JournalNote: Guests are unnamed; the event was a site fundraiser that included tarot readings and a scavenger hunt.
Read full account ›
Guests at a paid overnight stay in 2008 described flickering lights, a smell of tobacco where no one was smoking, and a child's handprint appearing on a bedspread.[4]
Legends & disputed stories
Stories told about the place that the records don’t confirm.
- Legend
Online retellings say servants died when lightning set the carriage house on fire in 1888 and that a later owner, Dr. Webb, murdered patients and was himself killed with his family; a commenter on one site says both stories were invented as themes for the haunted house.[8]
What the research shows: No historical source opened here mentions a Dr. Webb or an 1888 fire; the documented ownership runs from the Culbertsons (to 1899) to the American Legion and Historic New Albany.
Before you go
Planning a visit?
Tours only
Visits are by guided tour or organized event.
Access details ›
A state historic site run by Indiana State Museum and Historic Sites, seen on guided tours that need advance registration. Each fall the Carriage House behind the mansion hosts a paid haunted-house fundraiser, and the site runs seasonal ghost-story events; these are entertainment, not evidence. Check the official site for current tours.
Entry
Paid entry
Access last checked November 16, 2026. Confirm times and prices before you travel.
The history of Culbertson Mansion
Culbertson Mansion is a Second Empire house built just after the Civil War for William S. Culbertson, one of Indiana's wealthiest men, and now a state historic site. A former employee and leader of its Friends group described whistling, a passing female figure and a hushing voice, and staff and overnight guests have reported other odd events. A lurid murder story told online is disputed and appears to come from haunted-house fundraisers. Guided tours are available.
- Established
- 1867–1869
- Also known as
- W. S. Culbertson Mansion
The mansion
William S. Culbertson left New Market, Pennsylvania, at 21 and settled in New Albany, where he clerked in a dry-goods store before opening his own business. He started a utility company in 1854. During the Civil War, his National Register nomination says, a large shipment of cotton goods rose sharply in value, laying the foundation of his fortune. He retired from dry goods in 1868 to invest in local ventures, funded a widows' home and an orphans' home named for his second wife, Cornelia, and died in 1892 worth about $3.5 million.
The Second Empire house, with 25 or 26 rooms and a three-story cantilevered staircase, was built just after the war at a reputed cost of $120,000. The nomination gives 1868; other sources give 1867 to 1869. The family sold the house and contents in 1899. It later belonged to the American Legion, was threatened with demolition, and was bought by Historic New Albany, which restored it. It was listed on the National Register on June 28, 1974, and passed to the State of Indiana in 1976.
What people report
In 2009 a former employee who had led ghost tours for nine years and headed the Friends of Culbertson Mansion, told the IU Southeast student paper that she had heard whistling when alone, seen a female figure pass a doorway and heard a man's voice say "shhh." She said she had never felt threatened. She also described a police officer who, answering an alarm with her, saw a woman in a gray dress on the back veranda.
In 2008 the Indiana Daily Student, drawing on the Louisville Courier-Journal, reported that guests at a paid overnight stay described flickering lights, a smell of tobacco and a child's handprint on a bedspread. The county tourism bureau says staff and volunteers have reported electrical problems, figures, after-hours sounds and missing items, and that some refuse to work in the Carriage House.
A disputed story
Online retellings, including a 2022 high-school newspaper piece, say servants died when lightning set the carriage house on fire in 1888 and that a later owner, Dr. Webb, murdered patients there. No historical source opened here mentions either. A commenter describing herself as a former volunteer says both were invented as backstories for the haunted house.
Through the years
1854
1854
William S. Culbertson left New Market, Pennsylvania, at 21, clerked in a New Albany dry-goods store before opening his own business, started a utility company in 1854 and retired from dry goods in 1868 to invest in local ventures.[1]
1867–1869
Mansion built
The Second Empire mansion, with a three-story cantilevered staircase and about 25 rooms, was built just after the Civil War at a reputed cost of $120,000.[2][3][4]
Caveat: The nomination says built in 1868 with 26 rooms; the IU Southeast paper gives 1867 to 1869, and the Indiana Daily Student 1867 and 25 rooms.
1899
Family sells the house
The Culbertson family sold the house and furnishings in 1899; it later passed to the American Legion, was threatened with demolition, and was bought and restored by Historic New Albany.[5][1][3]
Caveat: The Horizon says a John McDonald owned it before his daughter sold it to the Legion; SoIN Tourism gives the Legion's use of the Carriage House as 1946–1964.
Also recorded
According to the nomination, Culbertson's fortune grew when cotton goods he and a relative had bought rose sharply in value during the Civil War.[2]
Caveat: Told anecdotally in the nomination, without a cited source.
The research conclusion
Why it has this rating
One traceable account: a former employee who led ghost tours described whistling, a passing female figure and a hushing voice (2009). Unnamed guests at a 2008 paid overnight, the officer's sighting she relayed and staff reports passed on by the tourism bureau are not counted, so this is Documented Accounts. The murder story told online is treated as a disputed legend.
Read the full written assessment ›
The mansion's history is solid: its 1974 National Register nomination and the Indiana State Museum agree on Culbertson, his fortune and the house's later owners, though they differ slightly on the building date and room count.
The ghost accounts come almost entirely from people connected with the site: a former employee who led ghost tours, unnamed staff and volunteers, and guests at paid overnight fundraisers. They are traceable but not independent. A story about a doctor named Webb who murdered patients in the carriage house, and servants killed by an 1888 lightning fire, is not supported by any historical source found here; a former volunteer says it was invented as a theme for the annual haunted house.
The sources behind the story
8 research references support this entry.
1Indiana State Museum and Historic SitesCulbertson Mansion Official or site history · Reference 01
Culbertson Mansion. Indiana State Museum and Historic Sites.
Official site page, checked 16 November 2026. Reliable for Culbertson's biography, the 1899 sale, state ownership from 1976 and current guided tours. It lists a Victorian ghost-stories evening but makes no haunting claims.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
2National Park Service, NPGalleryNational Register of Historic Places Inventory-Nomination Form: Culbertson Mansion Register or nomination · Reference 02
Richard K. Stem, Historic New Albany, Inc., National Register of Historic Places Inventory-Nomination Form: Culbertson Mansion. National Park Service, NPGallery, 1974-06-10.
The nomination (text layer present). Authoritative for the building (26 rooms, Second Empire, 'built ... in 1868' at a reputed $120,000) and Culbertson's role; its cotton-goods story is told anecdotally without a source. Coordinates 38°17'11" N, 85°48'45" W.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
3The Horizon (Indiana University Southeast)Culbertson Mansion spooks guests, raises money Newspaper · Reference 03
Eric McGuffin, Culbertson Mansion spooks guests, raises money. The Horizon (Indiana University Southeast), 2009-10-26.
Student newspaper feature with named sources. The earliest first-person account found, from a former employee. She led ghost tours, so her account belongs with staff reports. Also gives later ownership history (McDonald, American Legion, Historic New Albany).
Accessed November 16, 2026.
4Indiana Daily StudentSo. Ind. 'haunted' mansion gives tours Newspaper · Reference 04
So. Ind. 'haunted' mansion gives tours. Indiana Daily Student, 2008-09.
Short wire-style item that draws on the Louisville Courier-Journal (not consulted). Quotes the site manager on fundraising; the guests' experiences are reported without names. Month from the URL; the page shows no exact date.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
5SoIN Tourism (Clark-Floyd Counties Convention-Tourism Bureau)Ten Interesting (and scary) Things to Know About Culbertson Mansion's 'House of Anguish' Website · Reference 05
SoIN Tourism Staff, Ten Interesting (and scary) Things to Know About Culbertson Mansion's 'House of Anguish'. SoIN Tourism (Clark-Floyd Counties Convention-Tourism Bureau), 2025-10-01.
Tourism-bureau promotion of the haunted-house fundraiser (updated August 2026). Reliable for the event's history; its summary of unnamed staff experiences is promotional.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
6National Park Service, NPGalleryCulbertson Mansion (NRIS 74000019), National Register record Register or nomination · Reference 06
Culbertson Mansion (NRIS 74000019), National Register record. National Park Service, NPGallery, 1974-06-28.
Federal listing record; date published 6/28/1974.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
7HauntedPlaces.orgCulbertson Mansion Website · Reference 07
Culbertson Mansion. HauntedPlaces.org.
User-submitted ghost directory. Its main text repeats the Webb and lightning story; a January 8, 2016 comment by a reader signing as Mary S says these tales were made up by the organizers of the haunted house. Neither side gives evidence.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
8The Owl (Seymour High School)The Culbertson mansion's dark history Newspaper · Reference 08
Kayla Moriarty, The Culbertson mansion's dark history. The Owl (Seymour High School), 2022-05-06.
High-school newspaper feature built on ghost websites. Cited only as a place the Dr. Webb and lightning-fire story is published as fact. A reader comment on the page, from someone saying she volunteered at the mansion, disputes it.
Accessed November 16, 2026.























