Haunted Places USA

← Indianapolis Hannah House

Historic houseIndiana

Hannah House

Indianapolis, Indiana

Hannah House is an Italianate farmhouse of 1858 or 1859 on Indianapolis's south side, built by Alexander Hannah and listed on the National Register.

What do we know about Hannah House?

The ghost accounts are traceable but mostly second-hand. A former tenant from the 1960s and 1970s is credited with hearing glass break and seeing a man in a black suit; a parapsychologist and members of the owning family also described experiences. These reach us through later retellings rather than first publications we could read. A 2017 overnight investigation recorded little beyond ambiguous device responses and a reported scent, and the operators now sell paranormal investigations.

Documented Accounts

Our rating of the reports about Hannah House: Documented Accounts. At least one traceable published or first-hand account of an unexplained experience. We check that the reports exist, not the supernatural. The rating describes the evidence for the reports, not whether the place is haunted.

Reported accounts
5
Counted for the rating
4
Research sources
7

Counted for the rating: independent accounts we could trace to a witness. Retellings of the same story count once, and staff passing on what visitors said aren’t counted. How we count

Reported experiences don’t establish a supernatural cause.

Read our evidence assessment →
Tours onlyPaid entryVisitor information →

The hauntings

Accounts, encounters and stories associated with Hannah House.

What has been reported?

  • Apparitions
  • Voices
  • Smells
  • Cold spots

Phenomena described in accounts associated with this location — not independently verified events.

Reported experiences

5 published and reported accounts, each assessed by its source.

  • Account 01 · 2017

    A former tenant, 2017

    A former tenant who, with her husband, rented the house for an antiques store in the 1960s and 1970s, is credited with hearing the sound of crashing glass several times and seeing a man in a dark suit cross the upstairs hall.[5][2]

    • Apparitions
    • Voices
    Published accountReported by A former tenant, as retold by the Ghost Research Society (2017) and the Encyclopedia of Indianapolis (2023)

    Note: Known only from later retellings; the original publication of her account was not found or read.

    Read full account ›

    A former tenant who, with her husband, rented the house for an antiques store in the 1960s and 1970s, is credited with hearing the sound of crashing glass several times and seeing a man in a dark suit cross the upstairs hall.[5][2]

    View source 5View source 2

  • Account 02 · 1981

    Ruth Loux, 1981

    Dale Kaczmarek wrote that parapsychologist Ruth Loux described a sickening odor and unease in one room on many occasions, and that he first read the odor story in Richard Winer and Nancy Osborn Ishmael's 1981 book More Haunted Houses. The Encyclopedia of Indianapolis likewise repeats a…

    • Smells
    Published accountReported by Ruth Loux, parapsychologist, via More Haunted Houses (1981) as cited by Dale Kaczmarek

    Note: The 1981 book was not consulted; this rests on Kaczmarek's summary.

    Read full account ›

    Dale Kaczmarek wrote that parapsychologist Ruth Loux described a sickening odor and unease in one room on many occasions, and that he first read the odor story in Richard Winer and Nancy Osborn Ishmael's 1981 book More Haunted Houses. The Encyclopedia of Indianapolis likewise repeats a claim of a smell of rotting flesh in the first bedroom at the top of the stairs.[5][2]

    View source 5View source 2

  • Account 03 · 2017

    Former residents from the owning family, 2017

    Kaczmarek wrote that during a 1992 tour, members of the family who had lived in the house told him of many encounters there.[5]

    Published accountReported by Former residents from the owning family, as told to Dale Kaczmarek

    Note: The encounters are not described in detail.

    Read full account ›

    Kaczmarek wrote that during a 1992 tour, members of the family who had lived in the house told him of many encounters there.[5]

    View source 5

  • Account 04 · 2017

    Ghost Research Society investigators, 2017

    During a Ghost Research Society overnight investigation on September 23, 2017, most investigators reported nothing; one reported a strong gardenia scent and an attic motion sensor that went off, and a possible faint "hello" recording was judged uncertain.[5]

    • Smells
    • Voices
    Published accountReported by Ghost Research Society investigators (Dale Kaczmarek's team)

    Note: Most of the team reported no evidence; high attic EMF readings were put down to wiring.

    Read full account ›

    During a Ghost Research Society overnight investigation on September 23, 2017, most investigators reported nothing; one reported a strong gardenia scent and an attic motion sensor that went off, and a possible faint "hello" recording was judged uncertain.[5]

    View source 5

  • Account 05 · October 13, 2010

    Hannah House manager, 2010

    In 2010 the house manager told a student newspaper that visitors had smelled cherry pipe tobacco and felt cold drafts in an upstairs bedroom, and that the basement had the most reported activity.[6]

    • Cold spots
    • Smells
    Published accountReported by Hannah House manager, to The Reflector (2010)

    Note: Second-hand, from the people who run the house; the same article repeats the Underground Railroad story as fact.

    Read full account ›

    In 2010 the house manager told a student newspaper that visitors had smelled cherry pipe tobacco and felt cold drafts in an upstairs bedroom, and that the basement had the most reported activity.[6]

    View source 6

Legends & disputed stories

Stories told about the place that the records don’t confirm.

  • Legend

    A widely repeated story says Hannah sheltered people escaping slavery on the Underground Railroad and that some died in a basement fire; the Encyclopedia of Indianapolis calls this an urban myth with no evidence, and the 1976 nomination does not mention it.[6]


    What the research shows: A 2017 write-up reports the house's guide saying there is no written account of the fire story. A 2010 student newspaper repeated it as fact.

Before you go

Planning a visit?

Location

3801 Madison Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46227

Get directions

Tours only

Visits are by guided tour or organized event.

Access details ›

Privately owned historic house run as a rental venue. It opens for paid open-house tours on set days, offers private tours by phone, and sells overnight paranormal investigations; its 'most haunted' marketing is not evidence. Visit only at advertised times and check the official site first.

Entry

Paid entry

Access last checked November 16, 2026. Confirm times and prices before you travel.

The history of Hannah House

Hannah House is an Italianate farmhouse of 1858 or 1859 on Indianapolis's south side, built by Alexander Hannah and listed on the National Register. Ghost stories began with tenants who ran an antiques shop there in the 1960s and 1970s and spread through books and ghost-research groups: a bad smell in an upstairs bedroom, breaking-glass sounds and a man in a black suit. A popular Underground Railroad tale has no documentary support. The house opens for paid tours and ghost investigations.

Established
1859
Also known as
Hannah-Oehler-Elder House

The house

Alexander M. Hannah, born in Wayne County, Indiana, in 1821, trained as a harness maker, went to California in the 1850 gold rush and came home to farm south of Indianapolis. By 1857 he owned 240 acres. His accounts show he bought a load of brick in November 1858, and he built this Italianate house, with Greek Revival touches, in 1859, according to its National Register nomination; the Encyclopedia of Indianapolis and the house's own site say 1858. From 1860 until his death in 1895 he collected tolls on his stretch of the Indianapolis-Southport toll road, and he later served in the Indiana General Assembly.

Hannah married Elizabeth Jackson in 1872 and that year added a service building with a smokehouse, wash house, milk room and servants' quarters. Their only child was stillborn in 1875. With no heirs, his farm was divided after his death. In 1899 Roman Oehler, a Civil War veteran and jeweler, bought the house and 21 acres. His daughter Romena Oehler Elder lived there until the early 1960s, and her family had the house listed on the National Register in 1978.

The Underground Railroad story

A popular tale says Hannah sheltered people escaping slavery and that some died in a basement fire. The 1976 National Register nomination does not mention it, the Encyclopedia of Indianapolis calls it an urban myth with no supporting evidence, and the house's guide told a 2017 visitor there is no written account. It is treated here as legend.

What people report

The Encyclopedia of Indianapolis dates the ghost stories to the 1960s and 1970s, when a married couple rented the house for an antiques store. The wife, a former tenant, is credited with hearing glass crash repeatedly and seeing a man in a dark suit cross the upstairs hall. The encyclopedia also repeats a claim of a smell of decay in the first bedroom at the top of the stairs.

Ghost researcher Dale Kaczmarek wrote that a parapsychologist, Ruth Loux, described a sickening odor in one room, and that members of the family who lived there told him of encounters in 1992. His group's 2017 overnight visit found little: one investigator reported a gardenia scent and a triggered motion sensor, and a possible faint "hello" was uncertain. In 2010 a house manager told a student newspaper that visitors smelled pipe tobacco and felt cold drafts.

The north side of Hannah House, July 2010Source: Nyttend, Public domain

Through the years

  1. 1859

    House built

    Alexander M. Hannah, born in Wayne County, Indiana, in 1821, was a harness maker who went to California in the 1850 gold rush, returned to farm south of Indianapolis, owned 240 acres by 1857, bought brick for his…

    Read more ›

    Alexander M. Hannah, born in Wayne County, Indiana, in 1821, was a harness maker who went to California in the 1850 gold rush, returned to farm south of Indianapolis, owned 240 acres by 1857, bought brick for his house in November 1858 and built it in 1859, according to the National Register nomination (the Encyclopedia of Indianapolis and the house's own site give 1858).[1][2]

  2. 1860–1895

    1860–1895

    From 1860 until his death in 1895 Hannah collected tolls on the stretch of the Indianapolis-Southport toll road that crossed his land, and in later life he served in the Indiana General Assembly.[3][1]

  3. 1872

    Hannah marries; service building added

    Hannah married in 1872 and that year added a service building with a smokehouse, wash house, milk-cooling room and servants' quarters; the couple's only child was stillborn in 1875.[1][2]

    Caveat: The stillbirth date comes from the encyclopedia only.

  4. 1899

    Oehler family buys the house

    With no heirs, Hannah's farm was divided after his death in 1895; in 1899 Roman Oehler, a Civil War veteran and jeweler, bought the house and 21 acres, and his daughter Romena Oehler Elder's family lived there until the early 1960s.[1][2]

  5. 1978

    National Register listing

    The house was listed on the National Register of Historic Places on December 1, 1978.[4]

  6. 2008

    Annual paranormal gathering begins

    The house now opens for paid tours on set days and sells overnight paranormal investigations, and a paranormal enthusiasts' group has held an annual gathering there since 2008.[7][2]

The research conclusion

Why it has this rating

Four traceable accounts: a former tenant from the 1960s and 70s, a parapsychologist in a 1981 book, members of the owning family, and a 2017 Ghost Research Society investigation. Most reach us secondhand through one investigator's retellings, they describe different things, and the 2017 visit found little, so this is Documented Accounts rather than Well Documented.

Read our methodology →Assessed November 17, 2026 by Richard Pryn
Read the full written assessment ›

The house's history is well recorded by its 1976 National Register nomination and the Encyclopedia of Indianapolis. Neither supports the story that people escaping slavery hid or died in a basement there; the encyclopedia calls it an urban myth, and the house's own guide told a ghost-research group in 2017 that there is no written record of it.

The ghost accounts are traceable but mostly second-hand. A former tenant from the 1960s and 1970s is credited with hearing glass break and seeing a man in a black suit; a parapsychologist and members of the owning family also described experiences. These reach us through later retellings rather than first publications we could read. A 2017 overnight investigation recorded little beyond ambiguous device responses and a reported scent, and the operators now sell paranormal investigations.

The sources behind the story

7 research references support this entry.

  1. 1National Park Service, NPGalleryNational Register of Historic Places Inventory-Nomination Form: Hannah-Oehler-Elder House Register or nomination · Reference 01

    National Register of Historic Places Inventory-Nomination Form: Hannah-Oehler-Elder House. National Park Service, NPGallery, 1976-04.

    The nomination, prepared in April 1976 on behalf of the owning family. Scanned with no text layer; we read it through our own OCR, so small details (UTM references especially) may be misread. Authoritative for the building, Hannah's biography and ownership; it says nothing about the Underground Railroad or ghosts.

    Accessed November 16, 2026.

    View original source →

  2. 2Encyclopedia of Indianapolis (Polis Center, IU Indianapolis)Hannah House Website · Reference 02

    Jessica Erin Fischer, Hannah House. Encyclopedia of Indianapolis (Polis Center, IU Indianapolis), 2023-05.

    A scholarly local reference. Reliable for the house's history and for saying the Underground Railroad story is an urban myth. It summarizes the ghost claims without naming who first published each one. Its 1858 building date differs from the nomination's 1859.

    Accessed November 16, 2026.

    View original source →

  3. 3Visit IndyThe Historic Hannah House Website · Reference 03

    The Historic Hannah House. Visit Indy.

    Tourism directory listing. Confirms the address and describes Hannah as a state legislator; adds nothing on the ghost stories.

    Accessed November 16, 2026.

    View original source →

  4. 4National Park Service, NPGalleryHanna-Ochler-Elder House (NRIS 78000046), National Register record Register or nomination · Reference 04

    Hanna-Ochler-Elder House (NRIS 78000046), National Register record. National Park Service, NPGallery, 1978-12-01.

    Federal record of the listing; gives the date published as 12/1/1978. The NPS record misspells the names as 'Hanna-Ochler-Elder'.

    Accessed November 16, 2026.

    View original source →

  5. 5Ghost Research SocietyHannah House investigation Website · Reference 05

    Dale Kaczmarek, Hannah House investigation. Ghost Research Society, 2017.

    A ghost-research group's write-up of a September 23, 2017 investigation, with background from the author's 1992 visit and from the 1981 book More Haunted Houses. Cited as where these accounts were published. The page also carries unrelated text about a prison, which we ignored.

    Accessed November 16, 2026.

    View original source →

  6. 6The Reflector (University of Indianapolis)UIndy community weighs in on paranormal activities Newspaper · Reference 06

    Jacki Dillman, UIndy community weighs in on paranormal activities. The Reflector (University of Indianapolis), 2010-10-13.

    Student newspaper feature quoting the house manager at the time. It repeats the Underground Railroad basement story as fact, which the encyclopedia rejects.

    Accessed November 16, 2026.

    View original source →

  7. 7Historic Hannah House Official or site history · Reference 07

    Historic Hannah House. Historic Hannah House.

    The house's own site, checked 16 November 2026. Used for current access (open-house tours, rentals, paid overnight paranormal investigations). It calls the house one of the most haunted places in Indiana without evidence; that is marketing.

    Accessed November 16, 2026.

    View original source →

All our sources

Written by Haunted Places USA research. Ratings reviewed by Richard Pryn.

Facts last checked November 16, 2026. First published November 16, 2026. Updated November 17, 2026. Rated under our research methodology.

Spotted a mistake or have a source we should see? Send a correction.

Had an unexplained experience here yourself? Share it with us.