Haunted Places USA

Haunted Islands in America

Researched islands, the stories told about them and the accounts behind those stories, from across the United States.

A research insight

2 of the 3 islands we have researched have at least one traceable published or first-hand account of an experience. The other 1 rest on legend, retellings or unnamed reports so far.

We rate the reports, not the ghosts.

Our ratings assess the source and traceability of the accounts, not whether a place is genuinely haunted. How we rate

  • Color photograph of Alcatraz Island across San Francisco Bay, with the long cellhouse and lighthouse on its summit, a ferry crossing in front and the hills of Marin behind.

    Prison · San Francisco, CA

    Alcatraz Island

    Cell 14-D, Capone’s banjo, a strangled prisoner: famous stories, and how few of them lead back to a named witness.

    Documented AccountsOpen to visitors

    3 reported accounts · 7 sources

  • Black-and-white photograph of Fort Pulaski's long brick rear wall rising from the moat, with a wooden drawbridge leading to the arched entrance.

    Fort · GA

    Fort Pulaski National Monument

    Fort Pulaski, on Cockspur Island near Savannah, is a brick fort finished in 1847 and breached by Union rifled cannon in 1862.

    UnverifiedOpen to visitors

    2 reported accounts · 7 sources

  • Aerial view of Georges Island with the granite bastioned fort and parade ground surrounded by harbour water

    Fort · Boston, MA

    Fort Warren

    Fort Warren is a Civil War-era granite fort on Georges Island in Boston Harbor, where the Union held Confederate prisoners.

    Documented AccountsOpen to visitors

    2 reported accounts · 6 sources

Browse by state

Find islands in a particular state.

States with islands (3)

States without islands listings (yet)

We rate the reports, not the ghosts.

Every place here is researched from historical records, published accounts and sources you can check, with a clear assessment of the evidence and its limits.

Our research methodology