
Prison · San Francisco, CA
Alcatraz Island
Cell 14-D, Capone’s banjo, a strangled prisoner: famous stories, and how few of them lead back to a named witness.
3 reported accounts · 7 sources
Researched islands, the stories told about them and the accounts behind those stories, from across the United States.
2 of the 3 islands we have researched have at least one traceable published or first-hand account of an experience. The other 1 rest on legend, retellings or unnamed reports so far.
We rate the reports, not the ghosts.
Our ratings assess the source and traceability of the accounts, not whether a place is genuinely haunted. How we rate

Prison · San Francisco, CA
Cell 14-D, Capone’s banjo, a strangled prisoner: famous stories, and how few of them lead back to a named witness.
3 reported accounts · 7 sources

Fort · GA
Fort Pulaski, on Cockspur Island near Savannah, is a brick fort finished in 1847 and breached by Union rifled cannon in 1862.
2 reported accounts · 7 sources

Fort · Boston, MA
Fort Warren is a Civil War-era granite fort on Georges Island in Boston Harbor, where the Union held Confederate prisoners.
2 reported accounts · 6 sources
Find islands in a particular state.
States with islands (3)
States without islands listings (yet)
Every place here is researched from historical records, published accounts and sources you can check, with a clear assessment of the evidence and its limits.
Our research methodology