Haunted Places USA

New YorkHaunted Places

The stories, the history and the evidence behind 8 haunted places in New York, from churches to museums.

  • 8Researched places
  • 3Cities and towns
  • 6Place types
  • 6With traceable accounts
View on map

Photo: Lyndhurst (Jay Gould estate), Tarrytown, New York, Carol M. Highsmith, Library of Congress

Featured haunted places in New York

  • Black-and-white 1936 photograph of the Morris-Jumel Mansion from the southwest, a white Georgian house with a tall columned portico.

    Historic house · New York, NY

    Morris-Jumel Mansion

    The Morris-Jumel Mansion in Washington Heights, built in 1765, is Manhattan's oldest house and was Washington's headquarters in 1776.

    Documented AccountsClosed

    4 reported accounts · 5 sources

  • Aerial view of a star-shaped stone fort on a grassy bluff beside Lake Ontario, with the town beyond

    Fort · Oswego, NY

    Fort Ontario State Historic Site

    Fort Ontario in Oswego guarded the mouth of the Oswego River from 1755 and, in 1944–46, sheltered 982 refugees fleeing the Holocaust.

    Documented AccountsOpen to visitors

    3 reported accounts · 7 sources

  • The red brick Hotel Chelsea in New York with its iron balconies and vertical sign.

    Hotel · New York, NY

    Hotel Chelsea

    The Hotel Chelsea in Manhattan was completed in 1884 for co-operative apartments, and after an 11-year renovation it took guests again in 2022.

    Documented AccountsOpen to visitors

    3 reported accounts · 8 sources

Explore New York’s haunted places

8 places

New York haunted places map

Private and sensitive places have no pin, by design.

Explore on the full map

Which haunted places in New York can you visit?

7 of 8 can be visited, at least from outside. Check opening times and prices with each site before you go; we list how to visit, not hours or prices.

Tours only

1 place

Outside only

1 place

Not open to visitors

1 place

Please be respectful. Many of these places are historic homes, working businesses or active places of remembrance. Follow access rules, take guided tours where they’re required, and never enter private property.

New York’s legends and history

New York's places run from the colonial frontier to Manhattan's parlors. The French built the stone 'house of peace' at Old Fort Niagara in 1726–27, the oldest masonry building in the Great Lakes basin, and in 1755 British troops first fortified the point at the mouth of the Oswego River where Fort Ontario now stands. From 1944 to 1946 Fort Ontario held the only U.S. shelter for refugees fleeing the Holocaust. In the Hudson Valley, the Old Dutch Church of Sleepy Hollow was built for Frederick Philipse with the labor of Africans he enslaved.

In Manhattan, the Morris-Jumel Mansion of 1765 is the borough's oldest surviving house and was George Washington's headquarters in 1776, while the Merchant's House Museum keeps the 1832 row house where Gertrude Tredwell was born and died. Upstate, Genesee County's poorhouse housed poor, elderly, disabled and ill people for nearly 150 years and is now run privately as a ghost attraction called Rolling Hills Asylum. Lily Dale Assembly was founded in 1879 as a summer camp for Spiritualists, whose mediums we treat as a faith, not as ghost reports.

The state's most famous ghost is fiction: we found no record of the Headless Horseman before Washington Irving's 1820 story, and Old Fort Niagara's headless officer is a legend the folklorist Louis C. Jones told in 1944. The older accounts with a traceable origin are in Manhattan, where a governess described rappings at the Morris-Jumel Mansion around 1868 and a caretaker at the Merchant's House told The New York Times in 1953 of a twisting tassel.

Nearby states

Continue your journey in neighbouring states.

Stay the night

Our sister site Haunted Hotels USA, a related directory, covers hotels and inns with a haunted reputation, including which rooms you can ask for.

Visit Haunted Hotels USA