← Michigan Seul Choix Point Lighthouse
Seul Choix Point Lighthouse
Keepers, cigar smoke and the society that keeps the stories
Michigan
Seul Choix Point Lighthouse is an 1895 light station on Lake Michigan near Gulliver, now a volunteer-run museum.
What do we know about Seul Choix Point Lighthouse?
The ghost stories are mostly gathered and told by the historical society that runs the site, above all its president, Marilyn Fischer. Outside her accounts, the only named experience found is two travel writers' cold draft in 2005. The cigar smoke and the police alarm story are unattributed, and an investigator's audio recordings are her interpretation. Together they show a strong local tradition, not evidence of a haunting.
Our rating of the reports about Seul Choix Point Lighthouse: Documented Accounts. At least one traceable published or first-hand account of an unexplained experience. We check that the reports exist, not the supernatural. The rating describes the evidence for the reports, not whether the place is haunted.
- Reported accounts
- 5
- Counted for the rating
- 2
- Research sources
- 9
Counted for the rating: independent accounts we could trace to a witness. Retellings of the same story count once, and staff passing on what visitors said aren’t counted. How we count
Reported experiences don’t establish a supernatural cause.
Read our evidence assessment →The hauntings
Accounts, encounters and stories associated with Seul Choix Point Lighthouse.
What has been reported?
- Apparitions
- Moving objects
- Smells
- Voices
- Cold spots
Phenomena described in accounts associated with this location — not independently verified events.
Reported experiences
5 published and reported accounts, each assessed by its source.
Account 01 · October 2, 2005 · 2 versions
Marilyn Fischer, 2005
Marilyn Fischer, president of the Gulliver Historical Society, said she saw the former keeper's figure in a round upstairs mirror on three occasions and counted more than 100 times when the kitchen table's place settings had been disturbed, with forks turned tines-down as Townshend is said…
- Apparitions
- Moving objects
Published accountReported by Marilyn Fischer, Gulliver Historical Society (Texas Escapes, 2005)Note: Relayed by a visiting travel writer in 2005; Fischer leads the society that runs the site.
Read full account ›
Marilyn Fischer, president of the Gulliver Historical Society, said she saw the former keeper's figure in a round upstairs mirror on three occasions and counted more than 100 times when the kitchen table's place settings had been disturbed, with forks turned tines-down as Townshend is said to have laid them.[8]
Fischer has said publicly that she is confident the spirits are there and that the lighthouse has five spirits; the society keeps a log of hundreds of reports from guests and volunteers, and she has written four books about the ghosts.[1][2][9][7]
Note: Statements of belief and a society log, not individual accounts; the log's figure is given as 300+ (2010/2015) and the written stories as 150+ (2017).
View source 8View source 1View source 2View source 9View source 7
- Smells
No traceable witnessNote: No individual visitor is named in any source opened.
Account 03 · 2010
Promote Michigan, 2015
A story relayed in 2010 says that on a night when the alarm went off, police and a museum administrator found no one inside but a kitchen chair pulled out, and an officer said he heard a chair move and a man's voice from the kitchen.[7]
- Voices
- Moving objects
No traceable witnessNote: No officer or administrator is named; the same article links the alarms to teenagers later stopped nearby.
Read full account ›
A story relayed in 2010 says that on a night when the alarm went off, police and a museum administrator found no one inside but a kitchen chair pulled out, and an officer said he heard a chair move and a man's voice from the kitchen.[7]
Account 04 · October 2, 2005
Ken and Yvonne Rudine, 2005
Travel writers Ken and Yvonne Rudine, visiting in June 2005, found nothing unusual in their photographs of the mirror but felt a distinct cold downdraft on the stair landing.[8]
- Cold spots
Published accountReported by Ken and Yvonne Rudine (Texas Escapes, 2005)Note: A draft in an old building has ordinary explanations; Fischer told them such drafts are common there.
Read full account ›
Travel writers Ken and Yvonne Rudine, visiting in June 2005, found nothing unusual in their photographs of the mirror but felt a distinct cold downdraft on the stair landing.[8]
Account 05 · October 11, 2023
Kat Tedsen, 2023
Investigator and author Kat Tedsen said she personally experienced none of the reported phenomena but recorded audio in the first-floor bathroom that she interprets as answering "Mary" and "died in snow."[6]
Published accountReported by Kat Tedsen, co-author of Haunted Travels of Michigan (Great Lakes Echo, 2023)Note: Recorder output is the investigator's interpretation and is not counted as an account of an experience.
Read full account ›
Investigator and author Kat Tedsen said she personally experienced none of the reported phenomena but recorded audio in the first-floor bathroom that she interprets as answering "Mary" and "died in snow."[6]
Legends & disputed stories
Stories told about the place that the records don’t confirm.
- Legend
Local tradition, repeated in news and ghost writing, says that because winter prevented burial, Townshend's body was embalmed in the cellar and kept for about three weeks, and that a keeper's mother-in-law who died after a storm in February 1919 was kept in a first-floor room until the ground could be dug.[6][7]
What the research shows: Lighthouse Friends says only that Townshend lay in state in the parlor; the cellar and 1919 details come from news and ghost writing without a cited record and were not found in a historical source.
Before you go
Planning a visit?
Open to visitors
Parts of the inside are open to the public.
Access details ›
State-owned and run by the volunteer Gulliver Historical Society as a museum, with tower tours from Memorial Day into the fall, depending on volunteer guides. The society says its fog signal displays are free to view; tower tours and its occasional Halloween tours have been ticketed. Reached by county roads south of Gulliver; check the society's site before going.
Entry
Free and paid areas
Access last checked November 16, 2026. Confirm times and prices before you travel.
Approximate location, within about 1 km.
The history of Seul Choix Point Lighthouse
Seul Choix Point Lighthouse is an 1895 light station on Lake Michigan near Gulliver, now a volunteer-run museum. Keeper Joseph Townshend died there in 1910, and visitors say they smell his cigar smoke. Historical society president Marilyn Fischer has described seeing his figure in a mirror, and two travel writers felt a cold draft. The museum and tower open in season.
- Established
- 1892–1895
- Also known as
- Seul Choix Pointe Light Station
A light for the only choice
Seul Choix Point juts into northern Lake Michigan east of Manistique; its French name is traditionally said to mean "only choice," a sheltered bay on an exposed coast. Congress set aside money for a light in 1886. A temporary light was lit in 1892, and the permanent brick tower, about 79 feet to the top, went into service with a third-order Fresnel lens in August 1895.
The keepers
Joseph W. Townshend was head keeper from 1901 (some news and ghost sources say 1902) until he died in the dwelling in 1910. His body lay in state in the downstairs parlor until relatives could gather. Local tradition adds that because winter prevented a burial, he was embalmed in the cellar and kept for about three weeks, and that a keeper's mother-in-law who died after a storm in 1919 was also kept in the house. Those details come from ghost writing, not a historical record. William Blanchard then kept the light for 31 years.
The station was automated in 1972. The state bought it in 1977, the Gulliver Historical Society formed in 1987 and opened a museum in 1989, and the station is on the National Register.
The stories
The best-known story is cigar smoke in the living quarters, linked to Townshend, who reportedly had to smoke outdoors. No individual visitor is named. The society's president, Marilyn Fischer, told a visiting travel writer in 2005 that she had seen the keeper's figure in an upstairs mirror three times and found the dinner table settings disturbed more than 100 times. She has said the lighthouse has five spirits and has written four books about them.
The same 2005 visitors, Ken and Yvonne Rudine, saw nothing in their photographs but felt a cold downdraft on the stairs. A 2010 article told of police answering an alarm and hearing a chair move, without naming anyone. Investigator Kat Tedsen said she experienced none of these things herself; she relies on audio recordings she interprets as a woman's answers.
These are the beliefs and experiences of the people involved, mostly the site's own volunteers. They don't show that anyone remains there.
Through the years
1895
Permanent light goes into service
French sailors are said to have named the point the 'only choice' for shelter on this stretch of coast. Congress appropriated money for a light there on August 4, 1886. After bids twice came in over budget, work…
Read more ›
French sailors are said to have named the point the 'only choice' for shelter on this stretch of coast. Congress appropriated money for a light there on August 4, 1886. After bids twice came in over budget, work began with hired labor in 1891; a temporary light was lit on April 15, 1892, and the permanent brick tower, about 79 feet to the top, went into service with a third-order Fresnel lens on August 15, 1895.[1][2][3]
1984
July 19, 1984
Seul Choix Pointe Light Station was listed on the National Register of Historic Places on July 19, 1984, according to the National Park Service's records, as part of a thematic listing of Great Lakes light stations; the historical…
Read more ›
Seul Choix Pointe Light Station was listed on the National Register of Historic Places on July 19, 1984, according to the National Park Service's records, as part of a thematic listing of Great Lakes light stations; the historical society's own timeline gives August 28, 1988 for the State and National Register listing.[1][3]
1989
Historical society opens its museum
The station was automated in 1972 and the last keepers left. The Michigan Department of Natural Resources bought the property in 1977, and the Gulliver Historical Society, formed in 1987, opened a museum in the fog signal building…
Read more ›
The station was automated in 1972 and the last keepers left. The Michigan Department of Natural Resources bought the property in 1977, and the Gulliver Historical Society, formed in 1987, opened a museum in the fog signal building in 1989 and restored the tower and dwelling through the 1990s. Today the museum and tower open in season; the society says its fog signal displays are free to view, while tower and Halloween tours have been ticketed.[1][4][2][5]
The research conclusion
Why it has this rating
Two traceable origins: the historical society's president (a figure in a mirror, disturbed place settings) and two visitors (a cold downdraft, which is weak). An audio recording is device output and isn't counted.
Read the full written assessment ›
The station's history is well recorded by a detailed lighthouse-history site, the National Register record and the historical society, though they disagree on the Register date (1984 or 1988) and on the first year of Townshend's service.
The ghost stories are mostly gathered and told by the historical society that runs the site, above all its president, Marilyn Fischer. Outside her accounts, the only named experience found is two travel writers' cold draft in 2005. The cigar smoke and the police alarm story are unattributed, and an investigator's audio recordings are her interpretation. Together they show a strong local tradition, not evidence of a haunting.
The sources behind the story
9 research references support this entry.
1The Mining Journal (Marquette)Local lighthouse one of state's most haunted sites Newspaper · Reference 01
R. R. Branstrom, Local lighthouse one of state's most haunted sites. The Mining Journal (Marquette), 2024-10-25.
Regional daily. Gives the c. 1895 construction, Townshend as second keeper (1901–1910), NRHP 1984, the society's lease from the state, and quotes society president Marilyn Fischer ('We do have five spirits'). Also lists the society's paid Halloween tours.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
2Lighthouse FriendsSeul Choix Point Lighthouse, Michigan Website · Reference 02
Seul Choix Point Lighthouse, Michigan. Lighthouse Friends.
Detailed lighthouse-history site drawing on Lighthouse Board records. Gives the 1886 appropriation, the 1892 temporary light, the 1895 permanent light, the list of head keepers (Townshend 1901–1910) and his death in the dwelling, automation in 1972 and the historical society's museum. Briefly relays Marilyn Fischer's belief and the cigar-smoke, silverware and mirror stories without naming a publication. Undated.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
3National Park Service, NPGallerySeul Choix Pointe Light Station (NRIS 84001846) Register or nomination · Reference 03
Seul Choix Pointe Light Station (NRIS 84001846). National Park Service, NPGallery, 1984-07-19.
National Register record metadata, part of the U.S. Coast Guard Lighthouses and Light Stations on the Great Lakes thematic listing; significant years 1892, 1895 and 1925; location County Rd. 431. The nomination PDF is a 'not yet digitized' placeholder, so only metadata was read.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
4Gulliver Historical SocietySeul Choix Pointe museum and tower tours Official or site history · Reference 04
Seul Choix Pointe museum and tower tours. Gulliver Historical Society.
Descriptive title (page heading not captured). Checked 2026-11-16. Museum and tower open Memorial Day to mid-October, depending on volunteer guides; says the historical displays in the fog signal building are 'free to view' but gives no tower or tour fees.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
5Gulliver Historical SocietySeul Choix Pointe Lighthouse history Official or site history · Reference 05
Seul Choix Pointe Lighthouse history. Gulliver Historical Society.
Descriptive title (page heading not captured). Operating society's own preservation timeline: automation 1972, DNR purchase June 20, 1977, society formed October 8, 1987, museum opened August 6, 1989, restoration 1990–1996. Says the station was added to the State and National Registers on August 28, 1988, which conflicts with the NPGallery date of July 19, 1984.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
6Great Lakes Echo (Capital News Service, Michigan State University)The tale of a haunted lighthouse Newspaper · Reference 06
Kelsey Lester, The tale of a haunted lighthouse. Great Lakes Echo (Capital News Service, Michigan State University), 2023-10-11.
Student news service story (reprinted by The Mining Journal in January 2024). Quotes investigator Kat Tedsen, who said she found none of the reported phenomena herself but recorded audio she interprets as 'Mary' and 'died in snow'. It credits its construction dates to a ghost-travel site ('America's Haunted Road') and gives no source for its account of Townshend's body kept three weeks in the cellar or of the keeper's mother-in-law in 1919, so those are treated as tradition.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
7Promote MichiganShedding Light on Michigan’s Haunted Beacons Website · Reference 07
Dianna Stampfler, Shedding Light on Michigan’s Haunted Beacons. Promote Michigan, 2015-10-01.
Blog post by a lighthouse author and promoter, first published in Michigan HOME & Lifestyle Magazine in autumn 2010. Relays the society's log of 300+ occurrences and an alarm-night story with unnamed police officers and an unnamed administrator.
Accessed November 16, 2026.
8Texas EscapesKeeper of Seul Choix Point Website · Reference 08
Ken Rudine, Keeper of Seul Choix Point. Texas Escapes, 2005-10-02.
Travel writer's account of a June 2005 visit. The earliest source found that names a witness: it relays Marilyn Fischer's sightings in the mirror and her count of disturbed place settings, an alarm salesman's story told secondhand, and the Rudines' own experience (no anomalies in photos; a cold downdraft on the stairs).
Accessed November 16, 2026.
9Michigan Blue MagazineSpooky Lights Magazine · Reference 09
Marla R. Miller, Spooky Lights. Michigan Blue Magazine, 2017-10-01.
Regional magazine feature. Quotes Marilyn Fischer ('I'm confident they're there') and says the society has written up more than 150 stories from guests and volunteers, and that its haunted Halloween tours had been cancelled for lack of volunteers.
Accessed November 16, 2026.



















