Haunted Places USA

← Milwaukee The Pfister Hotel

HotelWisconsin

The Pfister Hotel

Milwaukee, Wisconsin

The Pfister, opened in 1893, is a grand Victorian hotel in the heart of Milwaukee, built for Guido and Charles Pfister to Henry C. Koch's design.

What do we know about The Pfister Hotel?

The ghost material is better attested than most, because named players have spoken for themselves: Carlos Gómez to the Associated Press in 2009, and Bryce Harper and other players in a 2013 ESPN The Magazine feature. But the experiences are varied, self-reported and told in a setting where teammates prank one another, and a local investigator suspects exactly that. Adrian Beltre's often-quoted 2001 story can't be traced to its first publication, and Charles Pfister's ghost has no named witness.

Documented Accounts

Our rating of the reports about The Pfister Hotel: Documented Accounts. At least one traceable published or first-hand account of an unexplained experience. We check that the reports exist, not the supernatural. The rating describes the evidence for the reports, not whether the place is haunted.

Reported accounts
5
Counted for the rating
2
Research sources
10

Counted for the rating: independent accounts we could trace to a witness. Retellings of the same story count once, and staff passing on what visitors said aren’t counted. How we count

Reported experiences don’t establish a supernatural cause.

Read our evidence assessment →
Open to visitorsPaid entryVisitor information →

The hauntings

Accounts, encounters and stories associated with The Pfister Hotel.

Reported experiences

5 published and reported accounts, each assessed by its source.

  • Account 01

    Fox Sports, 2023

    Adrian Beltre said he heard knocking in his room in 2001 and slept with a bat beside him.[4]

    Published account

    Note: No one has found the article in which this first appeared.

    Read full account ›

    Adrian Beltre said he heard knocking in his room in 2001 and slept with a bat beside him.[4]

    View source 4

  • Account 02

    Associated Press, 2009

    In July 2009 Carlos Gómez said his iPod switched songs without his touching it, and he ran down to the lobby.[5]

    Published account
    Read full account ›

    In July 2009 Carlos Gómez said his iPod switched songs without his touching it, and he ran down to the lobby.[5]

    View source 5

  • Account 03

    SFist, 2010

    In July 2010 Edgar Renteria and Pablo Sandoval paid their own way to stay at a different hotel.[6][7]

    Published account

    Note: The team confirmed it.

    Read full account ›

    In July 2010 Edgar Renteria and Pablo Sandoval paid their own way to stay at a different hotel.[6][7]

    View source 6View source 7

  • Account 04

    ESPN The Magazine, 2013

    Bryce Harper said that one morning in 2012 he found his clothes scattered across the floor and a table shifted, although his door was still latched.[7]

    Published account

    Note: His own account; he thought teammates were behind it.

    Read full account ›

    Bryce Harper said that one morning in 2012 he found his clothes scattered across the floor and a table shifted, although his door was still latched.[7]

    View source 7

  • Account 05

    Marquette Wire, 2025

    Players have played pranks on one another at the hotel, and a Milwaukee investigator suspects pranks explain the stories.[8][7]

    Published account
    Read full account ›

    Players have played pranks on one another at the hotel, and a Milwaukee investigator suspects pranks explain the stories.[8][7]

    View source 8View source 7

Legends & disputed stories

Stories told about the place that the records don’t confirm.

  • Legend

    Charles Pfister's ghost is supposedly seen on the grand staircase.[9]


    What the research shows: Nobody who saw him is named, and the hotel declines to comment.

  • Disputed

    A rumor holds that the hotel was built over a burying ground.[9]


    What the research shows: It rests on one man's recollection, printed in 1893, and he said no bones turned up.

Before you go

Planning a visit?

Location

424 E Wisconsin Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202

Get directions

Open to visitors

Parts of the inside are open to the public.

Access details ›

A working hotel owned by the Marcus family company. Its lobby, bars and restaurants are generally open to diners and visitors; check with the hotel before you go.

Entry

Paid entry

Confirm times and prices before you travel.

Staying the night?

Our sister site covers The Pfister Hotel as a place to stay: rooms, room requests and guest accounts.

The Pfister Hotel on Haunted Hotels USA

See The Pfister Hotel on the full map →

The history of The Pfister Hotel

The Pfister, opened in 1893, is a grand Victorian hotel in the heart of Milwaukee, built for Guido and Charles Pfister to Henry C. Koch's design. Its ghost lore comes mostly from visiting baseball players, several of whom have described strange nights there on the record, from Carlos Gómez's self-changing iPod to Bryce Harper's moved table. Players also prank one another, and the hotel's own legend, Charles Pfister on the staircase, has no named witness. The public rooms are generally open to visitors.

Established
1890-93 for Guido and Charles Pfister, designed by Henry C. Koch; tower added 1965

A grand hotel for Milwaukee

The architect Henry C. Koch drew the hotel for Guido Pfister and his son Charles. Building ran from 1890 to 1893, and Guido did not live to see it open. The 1986 National Register nomination for Milwaukee's East Side Commercial Historic District, which includes the hotel, describes it as the one grand hotel of the 1800s still standing downtown; the Pfister is not listed on its own.

At an auction in 1962 the hotel was bought by Ben Marcus, and his family's company still owns it. A 23-story tower followed in 1965 according to the Wisconsin Historical Society, though other sources give 1962 or 1964. A $20 million renovation was finished in November 2025.

A burying ground?

One rumor puts the hotel on top of an old graveyard. WUWM traced it to a newspaper piece of May 1893 in which one man remembered a burying ground there, and said no bones turned up when the ground was dug.

The ballplayers

Visiting baseball teams stay at the Pfister, and the players are the main source of its ghost stories. In July 2009 the Associated Press quoted Carlos Gómez saying that his iPod switched songs on its own and that he ran down to the lobby. A year later, the team confirmed, Edgar Renteria and Pablo Sandoval paid for rooms at a different hotel. For a 2013 ESPN The Magazine feature, Stacey Pressman collected first-hand accounts from several players. Among them was Bryce Harper, who said that one night in 2012 his clothes ended up strewn across the floor and a table was shifted, although his door was still latched; he suspected his teammates. The same piece includes skeptics. An older story, that Adrian Beltre heard knocking in 2001 and slept with a bat beside him, is widely retold, but nobody has found the original article. A 2023 Fox Sports headline reported that Mookie Betts chose an Airbnb instead.

Pranks and the founder

Ballplayers are known to prank one another during their stays, and a Milwaukee investigator interviewed by the Marquette Wire in 2025 suspects pranks lie behind many of the stories. The hotel's own legend is Charles Pfister, supposedly seen on the grand staircase. No one who saw him is named, and the hotel declines to talk about ghosts.

Through the years

  1. 1893

    The Pfister opens

    The hotel, built to Henry C. Koch's design for Guido Pfister and his son Charles, opened in 1893.[1][2]

    Caveat: Guido Pfister had died before the opening.

  2. 1962

    Bought by Ben Marcus

    At a 1962 auction the hotel went to Ben Marcus, and his family's company remains the owner.[3]

  3. 1965

    The tower is added

    The hotel gained a 23-story tower in 1965, by the Wisconsin Historical Society's date; elsewhere the year is given as 1962 or 1964.[2]

    Caveat: The year varies between sources.

  4. 1986

    National Register district listed

    The hotel counts toward Milwaukee's East Side Commercial Historic District, which entered the National Register in 1986.[1]

    Caveat: It has no listing of its own.

  5. 2025

    Renovation completed

    A renovation costing $20 million was finished in November 2025.[10]

The research conclusion

Why it has this rating

Two traceable origins: Carlos Gómez's own account to the Associated Press in 2009, and the players' first-hand accounts, Bryce Harper's among them, collected by Stacey Pressman for ESPN The Magazine in 2013, which count as one origin. Beltre's 2001 story can't be traced to where it first appeared, Sandoval and Renteria's move describes no experience, and Charles Pfister's ghost has no named witness.

Read our methodology →Assessed November 19, 2026 by Richard Pryn
Read the full written assessment ›

The building's history rests on the Wisconsin Historical Society's property record, the 1986 historic district nomination and the owners' own announcements.

The ghost material is better attested than most, because named players have spoken for themselves: Carlos Gómez to the Associated Press in 2009, and Bryce Harper and other players in a 2013 ESPN The Magazine feature. But the experiences are varied, self-reported and told in a setting where teammates prank one another, and a local investigator suspects exactly that. Adrian Beltre's often-quoted 2001 story can't be traced to its first publication, and Charles Pfister's ghost has no named witness.

The sources behind the story

10 research references support this entry.

  1. 1National Park ServiceEast Side Commercial Historic District: National Register nomination Archive or collection · Reference 01

    Vollmert, Wenger and Hatala, East Side Commercial Historic District: National Register nomination. National Park Service, 1986-09-23.

    The 1986 National Register nomination for the historic district: names Henry C. Koch and calls the Pfister the last downtown grand hotel of the 1800s.

    Accessed November 14, 2026.

    View original source →

  2. 2Wisconsin Historical SocietyProperty Record: 424 E Wisconsin Ave (Hotel Pfister) Archive or collection · Reference 02

    Property Record: 424 E Wisconsin Ave (Hotel Pfister). Wisconsin Historical Society.

    The Wisconsin Historical Society's property record: construction dates, the 1965 tower and the register dates.

    Accessed November 14, 2026.

    View original source →

  3. 3The Pfister HotelAbout Official or site history · Reference 03

    About. The Pfister Hotel.

    The hotel's own history page; supports the Marcus purchase and ownership.

    Accessed November 14, 2026.

    View original source →

  4. 4Fox SportsMookie Betts opts to stay at an Airbnb to avoid Milwaukee hotel with haunted history Website · Reference 04

    Mookie Betts opts to stay at an Airbnb to avoid Milwaukee hotel with haunted history. Fox Sports, 2023-05-10.

    A 2023 Fox Sports item on Mookie Betts choosing an Airbnb; it also retells Beltre's 2001 story.

    Accessed November 14, 2026.

    View original source →

  5. 5Associated Press (via Fox News)'Haunted' Milwaukee Hotel Spooks Baseball Teams Newspaper · Reference 05

    'Haunted' Milwaukee Hotel Spooks Baseball Teams. Associated Press (via Fox News), 2009-07-11.

    Associated Press report of 2009, carried by Fox News: Carlos Gómez's own account and the general manager's comments on guest privacy.

    Accessed November 14, 2026.

    View original source →

  6. 6SFistTwo Giants players switch hotels Website · Reference 06

    Jay Barmann, Two Giants players switch hotels. SFist, 2010-07-06.

    A 2010 SFist news item on Sandoval and Renteria moving hotels, with the team's confirmation.

    Accessed November 14, 2026.

    View original source →

  7. 7ESPN The MagazineThe haunting of MLB's A-List Magazine · Reference 07

    Stacey Pressman, The haunting of MLB's A-List. ESPN The Magazine, 2013-05-31.

    Stacey Pressman's 2013 ESPN The Magazine feature: first-hand accounts from several players, Harper among them, plus skeptics.

    Accessed November 14, 2026.

    View original source →

  8. 8Marquette WireStunts, spirits or secrets? A local investigator weighs in on the legend of the Pfister Hotel Newspaper · Reference 08

    Lance Schulteis, Stunts, spirits or secrets? A local investigator weighs in on the legend of the Pfister Hotel. Marquette Wire, 2025-10-28.

    A 2025 Marquette student newspaper article in which a local paranormal investigator takes a skeptical view.

    Accessed November 14, 2026.

    View original source →

  9. 9WUWMThe legend of the Pfister Hotel ghost Television or radio · Reference 09

    Becky Mortensen, The legend of the Pfister Hotel ghost. WUWM, 2022-10-31.

    Becky Mortensen's 2022 WUWM public radio report, which traces the burying-ground rumor to an 1893 article and records the hotel's refusal to comment.

    Accessed November 14, 2026.

    View original source →

  10. 10Marcus Hotels & ResortsThe Pfister Hotel Completes Multi-Phase Renovation Official or site history · Reference 10

    The Pfister Hotel Completes Multi-Phase Renovation. Marcus Hotels & Resorts, 2025-11-20.

    The owners' 2025 press release on the finished renovation.

    Accessed November 14, 2026.

    View original source →

All our sources