Haunted Places USA

← Crown Point Old Lake County Jail and Sheriff's House

PrisonIndiana

Old Lake County Jail and Sheriff's House

Crown Point, Indiana

The Old Lake County Jail and Sheriff's House in Crown Point is an 1882 sheriff's residence with a later jail wing, best known as the jail John Dillinger escaped from in March 1934.

What do we know about Old Lake County Jail and Sheriff's House?

The ghost material is thinner than the site's reputation suggests. The fullest account is a 2014 write-up by the Ghost Research Society, whose members reported noises, a shadow and being touched while also noting heavy noise from a nearby bar. A 2016 Ghost Hunters episode exists, but we saw only its listing. The foundation's own claims are general and come from a body that sells investigations.

Documented Accounts

Our rating of the reports about Old Lake County Jail and Sheriff's House: Documented Accounts. At least one traceable published or first-hand account of an unexplained experience. We check that the reports exist, not the supernatural. The rating describes the evidence for the reports, not whether the place is haunted.

Reported accounts
4
Counted for the rating
1
Research sources
8

Counted for the rating: independent accounts we could trace to a witness. Retellings of the same story count once, and staff passing on what visitors said aren’t counted. How we count

Reported experiences don’t establish a supernatural cause.

Read our evidence assessment →
Tours onlyPaid entryVisitor information →

The hauntings

Accounts, encounters and stories associated with Old Lake County Jail and Sheriff's House.

What has been reported?

  • Being touched
  • Doors
  • Smells
  • Voices
  • Shadow figures
  • Apparitions

Phenomena described in accounts associated with this location — not independently verified events.

Reported experiences

4 published and reported accounts, each assessed by its source.

  • Account 01 · 2014

    Ghost Research Society, 2014

    Members of the Ghost Research Society who investigated in July 2014 reported cell doors banging, a loud bang and a shadow in a cell, being touched, a breathy whisper and a smell of paint with no source; others noted heavy noise from a nearby bar and…

    • Being touched
    • Doors
    • Smells
    • Voices
    • Shadow figures
    Published accountReported by Ghost Research Society (Stan Suho, Marge Sucha, Kathie Para, Dale Kaczmarek and others), 2014

    Note: Investigators' own write-up; the group leader called the site very active, while one member reported only door noises and another described the outside contamination as extreme.

    Read full account ›

    Members of the Ghost Research Society who investigated in July 2014 reported cell doors banging, a loud bang and a shadow in a cell, being touched, a breathy whisper and a smell of paint with no source; others noted heavy noise from a nearby bar and traffic.[4]

    View source 4

  • Account 02 · September 14, 2016

    Ghost Hunters, 2016

    The jail was featured in the Ghost Hunters episode "Public Poltergeist Number 1," aired September 14, 2016, whose listing describes reports of sealed areas and doors reopening.[5]

    • Doors
    Published accountReported by Ghost Hunters, season 11 (2016)

    Note: Only the episode listing was read; what the investigators said they experienced was not checked.

    Read full account ›

    The jail was featured in the Ghost Hunters episode "Public Poltergeist Number 1," aired September 14, 2016, whose listing describes reports of sealed areas and doors reopening.[5]

    View source 5

  • Account 03 · 2026

    Old Sheriff's House Foundation, 2026

    The Old Sheriff's House Foundation says experiences in the jail and house have been physical, emotional, mental and visual, and sells private paranormal investigations there.[6][7]

    Published accountReported by Old Sheriff's House Foundation (website)

    Note: Operator's promotional page; no witnesses, dates or specific experiences are given.

    Read full account ›

    The Old Sheriff's House Foundation says experiences in the jail and house have been physical, emotional, mental and visual, and sells private paranormal investigations there.[6][7]

    View source 6View source 7

  • Account 04

    Crown Point Community Library

    A Crown Point Community Library page says voices are often heard in the cells and walkways and that apparitions, perhaps of a prisoner or guard, have been seen.[8]

    • Apparitions
    • Voices
    No traceable witnessReported by Crown Point Community Library (website)

    Note: No witness, date or original source is given.

    Read full account ›

    A Crown Point Community Library page says voices are often heard in the cells and walkways and that apparitions, perhaps of a prisoner or guard, have been seen.[8]

    View source 8

Before you go

Planning a visit?

Location

232 S Main St, Crown Point, IN 46307

Get directions

Tours only

Visits are by guided tour or organized event.

Access details ›

Run by the nonprofit Old Sheriff's House Foundation, which offers historic house and jail tours and night tours, and also sells private paranormal investigations and tickets to a seasonal haunted-house attraction. Its ghost marketing is not evidence. Check the official site for current tour dates and prices.

Entry

Paid entry

Access last checked November 16, 2026. Confirm times and prices before you travel.

The history of Old Lake County Jail and Sheriff's House

The Old Lake County Jail and Sheriff's House in Crown Point is an 1882 sheriff's residence with a later jail wing, best known as the jail John Dillinger escaped from in March 1934. Its ghost reputation comes mainly from paranormal groups, a 2016 Ghost Hunters episode and the foundation that runs it, which sells paranormal investigations. Tours are offered by the foundation.

Established
1882
Also known as
Lake County Sheriff's House and Jail

Sheriff's house and jail

The Lake County Sheriff's House and Jail on South Main Street in Crown Point was built in 1882, replacing a plank jail about thirty years old. According to its National Register nomination, it was the county's first permanent building of this kind and cost $24,000. The sheriff's family lived in the Second Empire house at the front, with the jail behind.

As the county grew, the original one-story jail wing proved too small. Around 1910 it was replaced by a three-story brick jail, which was extended in stages until it reached its present form in 1934. The residence requirement for sheriffs ended in 1958, when the house became offices. The jail stayed in use until a new county complex opened in 1974, after which the building stood largely empty. The Old Sheriff's House Foundation was formed to save it, and it was listed on the National Register in January 1989.

Dillinger's escape

On March 3, 1934, John Dillinger escaped from the jail, which had been described as escape-proof, together with another prisoner, Herbert Youngblood. The Mob Museum says Dillinger threatened guards with a fake wooden gun and drove off in Sheriff Lillian Holley's car. How he got the gun is disputed: Dillinger claimed he carved it, a later account credits his lawyer's investigator, and the 1988 nomination repeats a story that a bribed judge smuggled in a real pistol.

Source: Nyttend, Public domain

Through the years

  1. 1882

    Sheriff's house and jail built

    The sheriff's house and jail was built in 1882 at a cost of $24,000, replacing a plank jail about thirty years old, and was Lake County's first permanent building of this kind.[1][2]

  2. 1910

    New jail wing

    Around 1910 the original one-story jail wing was replaced by a three-story brick jail, which was extended in stages until it reached its current form in 1934.[1]

  3. 1934

    Dillinger escapes

    On March 3, 1934, John Dillinger escaped from the jail with another prisoner, Herbert Youngblood, locking up jail staff and driving away in Sheriff Lillian Holley's car.[1][3][2]

  4. 1934

    March 3, 1934

    How Dillinger was armed is disputed: he claimed he carved a wooden gun himself, the Mob Museum credits his lawyer's investigator with obtaining it, and the 1988 nomination repeats a story that a bribed judge smuggled in a real pistol.[3]

    Caveat: Conflicting accounts; the nomination itself says 'numerous tall tales' surround the escape.

    Contradicted by source 1

  5. 1974

    Jail vacated

    The requirement for sheriffs to live in the house ended in 1958, when it became law-enforcement offices; the jail stayed in use until a new county complex opened in 1974, and the building then stood largely vacant.[1]

  6. 1989

    National Register listing

    The Lake County Sheriff's House and Jail was listed on the National Register of Historic Places on January 4, 1989, nominated by the newly formed Old Sheriff's House Foundation.[1]

The research conclusion

Why it has this rating

One traceable account: named members of the Ghost Research Society wrote up a 2014 investigation with cell doors banging, a shadow and touches. The 2016 Ghost Hunters episode is known only from a listing that describes other people's reports, and the foundation's claims name no one. Dillinger's 1934 escape is documented history and doesn't raise the rating.

Read our methodology →Assessed November 17, 2026 by Richard Pryn
Read the full written assessment ›

The building's history is well recorded by its 1988 National Register nomination, and the Dillinger escape is a matter of record, though how he got his weapon has been told in conflicting ways for decades.

The ghost material is thinner than the site's reputation suggests. The fullest account is a 2014 write-up by the Ghost Research Society, whose members reported noises, a shadow and being touched while also noting heavy noise from a nearby bar. A 2016 Ghost Hunters episode exists, but we saw only its listing. The foundation's own claims are general and come from a body that sells investigations.

The sources behind the story

8 research references support this entry.

  1. 1National Park Service, NPGalleryLake County Sheriff's House and Jail, National Register of Historic Places Registration Form (NRIS 88003039) Register or nomination · Reference 01

    John Hein (Old Sheriff's House Foundation), form prepared, Lake County Sheriff's House and Jail, National Register of Historic Places Registration Form (NRIS 88003039). National Park Service, NPGallery, 1988-09-07.

    The nomination form and supplementary listing record (listed January 4, 1989). Read by OCR of a scanned PDF, so small misreadings are possible. Prepared by the foundation seeking to save the building. Reliable for construction, additions and dates of use; its account of the Dillinger escape (a smuggled pistol) repeats a story it admits is surrounded by 'tall tales'. The preparer's surname is partly cut off in the scan.

    Accessed November 16, 2026.

    View original source →

  2. 2Visit Indiana (Indiana Destination Development Corporation)Visit the Jailhouse Made Famous by John Dillinger Website · Reference 02

    Visit the Jailhouse Made Famous by John Dillinger. Visit Indiana (Indiana Destination Development Corporation), 2013-09-07.

    State tourism blog post with contributions from Partners in Preservation. Useful summary of the building's dates and the escape (shortly after 9 a.m., March 3, 1934, with Herbert Youngblood); no ghost claims.

    Accessed November 16, 2026.

    View original source →

  3. 3The Mob MuseumJohn Dillinger's wooden gun and death mask preserve notorious moments in his life Website · Reference 03

    John Dillinger's wooden gun and death mask preserve notorious moments in his life. The Mob Museum, 2024-07-22.

    Museum blog post about a wooden gun in its collection. Details of the escape (wooden gun, Sheriff Lillian Holley's car, Herbert Youngblood) and the dispute over who made the gun; draws on the lawyer Louis Piquett's account, which is itself self-interested.

    Accessed November 16, 2026.

    View original source →

  4. 4Ghost Research SocietyCrown Point Jail Investigation Website · Reference 04

    Dale Kaczmarek and team, Crown Point Jail Investigation. Ghost Research Society, 2014.

    A paranormal group's write-up of its July 26, 2014 investigation, with named members and their individual reports. It is where these accounts were published; it also records noise contamination from a nearby tavern and traffic, and that some members experienced little.

    Accessed November 16, 2026.

    View original source →

  5. 5TVmazeGhost Hunters, season 11, episode 7: Public Poltergeist Number 1 Website · Reference 05

    Ghost Hunters, season 11, episode 7: Public Poltergeist Number 1. TVmaze, 2016-09-14.

    Episode listing only (airdate September 14, 2016, and synopsis). The episode itself was not watched; the synopsis is promotional.

    Accessed November 16, 2026.

    View original source →

  6. 6Old Sheriff's House FoundationOld Sheriff's House Foundation home page Official or site history · Reference 06

    Old Sheriff's House Foundation home page. Old Sheriff's House Foundation.

    Official site of the nonprofit that runs the building, checked 16 November 2026. Used for what is offered (historic tours, night tours, paid paranormal investigations, a ticketed haunted-house attraction). Tour and night-tour pages returned errors (429) and were not read.

    Accessed November 16, 2026.

    View original source →

  7. 7Old Sheriff's House FoundationThe Paranormal Official or site history · Reference 07

    The Paranormal. Old Sheriff's House Foundation.

    The foundation's page selling private paranormal investigations. Cited only as where the operator's general claims are published; it names no witnesses, dates or rooms and has a commercial interest.

    Accessed November 16, 2026.

    View original source →

  8. 8Crown Point Community Library (Indiana Room)Haunted Crown Point Website · Reference 08

    Haunted Crown Point. Crown Point Community Library (Indiana Room).

    Local library history page. Repeats general claims of voices and apparitions at the jail without naming any witness or date; recommends Judith Tometczak's book Haunted Crown Point, Indiana, which was not consulted.

    Accessed November 16, 2026.

    View original source →

All our sources

Written by Haunted Places USA research. Ratings reviewed by Richard Pryn.

Facts last checked November 16, 2026. First published November 16, 2026. Updated November 19, 2026. Rated under our research methodology.

Spotted a mistake or have a source we should see? Send a correction.

Had an unexplained experience here yourself? Share it with us.